"岳飞是民族英雄吗？
同学甲： “岳飞战功卓著，多次打败入侵的金兵，保卫了汉族大好河山，把他称为『民族英雄』，真是实至名归呢！"
同学乙：“金国的女真族现在已是中华民族的一分子。换言之，宋金战争不过是一场兄弟之战，而不属于民族战争。把岳飞视为『民族英雄』，当然并不恰当啊！""
Translation: "Was Yue Fei a ethnic hero?
Student A: Yue Fei distinguished himself in battle, repeatedly defeating invading [Jurchen] Jin soldiers and protecting the Han people's beloved motherland. Calling him an "ethnic hero" is to recognise his achievements!
Student B: The Jin Kingdom's Jurchen have since become part of the Chinese people. In other words, the Jin-Song war was only a fight between relatives, not a racialised war. Calling Yue Fei an "ethnic hero" is surely not appropriate!"
Since this is in traditional characters, this is probably from a Hong Kong or Taiwan textbook.
