'Healthy' 26-year-old man killed by MAiD for 'mental illness' - "A 26-year-old Ontario man has been euthanized by medical assistance in dying (MAiD) despite his doctor describing him as "young and healthy." Kiano Vafaeian died from MAiD on December 30, something his mother, Margaret Marsilla, announced in a Facebook post on Tuesday, stating the doctor who approved his euthanasia, found a "loophole" to kill her son. Vafaeian received MAiD in Vancouver by a now household name in MAiD — Dr. Ellen Wiebe, referred to as "DR DEATH #2."... Vafaeian had previously tried to apply for MAiD in 2022 for diabetes and visual impairment. "Four years ago, here in Ontario, we were able to stop his euthanasia and get him some help. He was alive because people stepped in when he was vulnerable and not capable of making a final, irreversible decision," wrote Marsilla in the Facebook post... Vafaeian was 23 years old at the time, he had diabetes and had lost his vision in one eye — and he had no job, girlfriend, or plan for the future... Vafaeian was still euthanized at the end of 2025 due to "mental illness." As Marsilla wrote, "This approval occurred despite euthanasia for mental illness being banned until 2027."... "The actions of DR ELLEN WIEBE reveal a pattern of coldness and disregard for vulnerable human life that I can no longer stay silent about, just that scary smile shows her entitlement for taking peoples lives….." "This is not healthcare. This is a failure of ethics, accountability, and humanity." "No parent should ever have to bury their child because a system — and a doctor — chose death over care, help, or love," Marsilla wrote."
Mark Hemingway on X - ""Ontario’s euthanasia regulators have tracked 428 cases of possible criminal violations — and not referred a single case to law enforcement, say leaked documents.""
Wesley Yang on X - "It was always going to end up like this -- a rapid cascade down the slippery slope to state-sanctioned medicalized murder done with absolute impunity. All assurances to the contrary were always going to be falsified and there would be no accountability mechanism after all of it was disclosed."
Marlene Robertson🇨🇦 on X - "For all the dumbass maga in the back: MAID is a voluntary, regulated medical procedure with very strict eligibility rules. It applies to those over 18 and who are mentally competent. It’s an option when you have a grievous and incurable medical condition that is causing intolerable suffering and pain."
Kelly on X - "I’m about as far left as you can get… but we do have problems with MAiD in Canada. How do I know? It was “offered” to me in lieu of care. I’m disabled, I was alone, my conditions expensive. Yes I was allowed to say “No”, but no alternative care was offered. That’s coercion."
Tellingly, OP goes on about "Nazis" in its bio
Coddled Affluent Professional on X - "In Canada, you can get euthanized more quickly than you can get an MRI."
Disabled Canadians ‘Often’ Offered Euthanasia Unprompted, Advocate Tells MPs - "Canadians with disabilities are being offered medical assistance in dying (MAID) when accessing health care for regular health concerns, a disabilities advocate told a parliamentary committee on Oct. 8. “People with disabilities are now very much afraid in many circumstances to show up in the health care system with regular health concerns, because often MAID is suggested as a solution to what is considered to be intolerable suffering,” Krista Carr, CEO of Inclusion Canada, told the Parliamentary Finance Committee on Oct. 8. When asked for more details by Conservative MP Garnett Genuis, Carr said she hears complaints “weekly,” and the disability community wants the repeal of Track 2 MAID, which applies to people whose natural death is not reasonably foreseeable... The Liberal government introduced MAID in 2016 after a Supreme Court ruling found that the absence of such a program violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The program has since been expanded and is set to include individuals with mental health conditions by 2027. The program drew further controversy in 2022 when military veterans said they had been offered MAID by a Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC) agent after approaching the department for support. VAC responded by saying all the incidents involved one agent who “is no longer employed with the Department.” There have also been cases of individuals seeking MAID due to financial hardship, including a 54-year-old man in St. Catharines who suffered from chronic back pain and feared becoming homeless in 2022. He applied for MAID but changed his mind after receiving community support."
Weird. Left wingers told us this would never happen. And they still insist it's not happening, and that those who are euthanised are all terminally ill and would die soon anyway and only religious extremists have concerns about euthanasia
Where does Sarah Palin go for her apology? - "Canada, whose lawmakers, celebrities, and influencers often boast about their “free” healthcare and stringent anti-gun laws, recorded an astonishing 16,499 MAID suicides, or legalized doctor-assisted suicides, in 2024, following 22,535 such requests that year. In 2023, there were approximately 15,500 MAID suicides. To put things into perspective, 2023’s recorded figure gives us a per capita rate of 37 MAID suicides per 100,000 people. During the same year, the United States reported 17,927 firearm homicides, resulting in a per capita rate of five gun-related murders per 100,000 people. Even if you combine 2023’s firearm homicides with all other gun-related deaths from that year, including suicides (27,300), law enforcement-related shootings (604), accidental shooting deaths (463), and what the CDC calls “undetermined circumstances” (434), that gives us a rate of only 13.7 gun-related deaths per 100,000 people, compared to Canada’s rate of 37 MAID suicides per 100,000. Put another way, a Canadian is nearly three times more likely to die by MAID than an American is to die by a gunshot, whether intentional or not. How’s that for perspective?... the number of Canadians lining up to commit suicide is increasing each year, and not by just a little, but exponentially. There is a broader conversation to be had about Canada’s culture of despair. But the more urgent and troubling issue is the one where, as Palin warned all those years ago, medical professionals within a “universal healthcare” system are evidently encouraging patients to consider death as an alternative to medical care, even when the patients themselves have expressed no such desire to die... In 2018, a patient with a degenerative neurological condition at a London, Ontario hospital secretly recorded staff offering him suicide, despite his repeated requests for home care support. In 2022, a paraplegic Paralympian and veteran was offered MAID by a Veterans Affairs Canada caseworker when she requested a wheelchair ramp for her home, with the worker suggesting suicide as an alternative to feeling “desperate.” A separate internal Veterans Affairs investigation confirmed four similar incidents between 2019 and 2022 where the same employee offered suicide services to veterans seeking help for post-traumatic stress disorder or disabilities, not end-of-life care. In 2023, a Vancouver woman seeking psychiatric care for chronic suicidal ideation had a clinician describe the MAID process in detail without her prompting, which the patient felt undermined her suicide prevention efforts. In 2019, a man in British Columbia was approved for MAID amid family concerns that it had been suggested while he was vulnerable in the hospital for suicidal ideation. In 2024, a Montreal woman with spina bifida was offered MAID twice by hospital staff during unrelated treatment, and a woman from Nova Scotia was asked about MAID before breast cancer surgery despite not being terminally ill. Another disabled woman was suggested MAID by her physiotherapist while seeking help for a bruised hip. If you think this is bad, know it will get much worse, especially as Canada prepares to broaden its already generous MAID qualifications to include people with mental health problems. This is in addition to separate proposals to make MAID suicide services available to “mature minors,” that is, patients under the age of 18 who are “found to have the requisite decision-making capacity,” as well as infants under one year old in cases of “severe deformities.” Even without the proposed expansions, we know that things will get worse in Canada because we know what happens in modern societies where secular understandings of convenience and quality of life inform medical and lifestyle decisions. Just look at what Europe did to children with Down syndrome — it aborted them into near-extinction... Remember, Canada is a country that, until relatively recently, had fewer MRI machines than Pittsburgh. It’s also a country with a median healthcare wait time of an astonishing 28.6 weeks. Why wouldn’t Canada try to ease the pressure on its healthcare system by encouraging the chronically ill, the elderly, and the mentally unstable to commit suicide? If a government is seeking a way to manage an already unwieldy budget, it might naturally consider removing those who contribute little but consume a great deal — the crippled, the infirm, the feeble, and the mentally impaired. It has always seemed odd that Palin’s warning was met with ridicule and mockery, dismissed as complete lunacy, the suggestion that a board overseen by nameless bureaucrats would eventually invent for itself the power to decide who should and should not have access to government-run medical care. Governments operate on a limited resource: money. What do all businesses do when an asset incurs more debits than credits? They cut that asset. Governments are no different. It’s only logical that Canada is pushing for the liquidation of those whose mere existence is a drain on the treasury; it would be surprising if it weren’t."
James Rosen on X - "A fascinating examination of medically assisted suicide in #Canada by @BecketAdams @washexaminer. Most striking are the accounts of instances, secretly recorded, where patients pleaded for care while authorities pushed them toward suicide."
Erik Lindberg on X - Can confirm. I was in the hospital with pneumonia and one of my doctors suggested that if I needed a ventilator that I just refuse it and pass on because it was easier. I had quite an argument with him. He was sure that I would be better off dead than deal with the discomfort of being intubated."
Left wing logic: if a medical professional suggests euthanasia, there's no coercion and there's nothing wrong. But if a medical professional suggests losing weight, that's fat shaming and unethical
Rushing to death in Canada’s MAiD regime - "A recent federal consultation explored extending MAiD to those who lack capacity via advance directives, an approach Quebec has already adopted, despite its criminal status under federal law. Despite its compassionate framing, investigative journalists and government reports reveal troubling patterns where inadequate exploration of reversible suffering – such as lack of access to medical treatments, poverty, loneliness, and feelings of being a burden – have driven Canadians to choose death. As described by our former Disability Inclusion Minister, Canada’s system at times makes it easier to access MAiD than to receive basic care like a wheelchair. With over 60,000 MAiD cases by the end of 2023, the evidence raises grave concerns about Canada’s MAiD regime...
In the same-day or next-day MAiD report, Mrs. B, in her 80s, after complications from surgery, opted for palliative care, leading to discharge home. She later requested a MAiD assessment, but her assessor noted she preferred palliative care based on personal and religious values. The next day, her spouse, struggling with caregiver burnout, took her to the emergency department, but she was discharged home. When a request for hospice palliative care was denied, her spouse contacted the provincial MAiD coordination service for an urgent assessment. A new assessor deemed her eligible for MAiD, despite concerns from the first practitioner, who questioned the new assessor on the urgency, the sudden shift in patient perspective, and the influence of caregiver burnout. The initial assessor requested an opportunity for re-evaluation, but this was denied, with the second assessor deeming it urgent. That evening, a third MAiD practitioner was brought in, and Mrs. B underwent MAiD that night. The focus should have been on ensuring adequate palliative care and support for Mrs. B and her spouse. Hospice and palliative care teams should have been urgently re-engaged, given the severity of the situation. Additionally, the MAiD provider expedited the process despite the first assessor’s and Mrs. B’s concerns without fully considering the impact of her spouse’s burnout. The report also has worrying trends suggesting that local medical cultures—rather than patient choice—could be influencing rushed MAiD. Geographic clustering, particularly in Western Ontario, where same-day and next-day MAiD deaths occur most frequently, raises concerns that some MAiD providers may be predisposed to rapidly approve patients for quick death rather than ensuring patients have access to adequate care or exploring if suffering is remediable. This highlights a worrying trend where the speed of the MAiD provision is prioritized over patient-centered care and ethical safeguards.
Consent has been central to Canadians’ acceptance of the legalization of euthanasia and assisted suicide. However, some cases in these reports point to concerns already raised by clinicians: the lack of thorough capacity assessments and concerns that individuals may not have freely chosen MAiD. In the waiver of final consent report, Mr. B, a man with Alzheimer’s, had been approved for MAiD with such a waiver. However, by the scheduled provision date, his spouse reported increased confusion. Upon arrival, the MAiD provider noted that Mr. B no longer recognized them and so chose not to engage him in discussion at all. Without any verbal interaction to determine his current wishes or understanding, Mr. B’s life was ended. In the same-day or next-day MAiD report, Mr. C, diagnosed with metastatic cancer, initially expressed interest in MAiD but then experienced cognitive decline and became delirious. He was sedated for pain management. Despite the treating team confirming that capacity was no longer present, a MAiD practitioner arrived and withheld sedation, attempting to rouse him. It was documented that the patient mouthed “yes” and nodded and blinked in response to questions. Based on this interaction, the MAiD provider deemed the patient to have capacity. The MAiD practitioner then facilitated a virtual second assessment, and MAiD was administered...
As early as 2020, the Chief Coroner of Ontario identified cases where patients received MAiD without well-documented capacity assessments, even though their medical records suggested they lacked capacity. Further, when Dr. Leonie Herx, past president of the Canadian Society of Palliative Medicine, testified before Parliament about MAiD frequently occurring without capacity, an MP dismissed her, advising Parliament to be cautious about considering seriously evidence under parliamentary immunities that amounted to malpractice allegations, which should be handled by the appropriate regulatory bodies or police. These dismissive comments stand in stark contrast with the gravity of assessing financial capacity, and yet the magnitude is greater when ending life. By way of comparison, for my father, an Ontario-approved capacity expert conducted a rigorous evaluation before declaring him incapable of managing his finances. This included a lengthy interview, collateral history, and review of financial documents—yet no such rigorous capacity assessment is mandated for MAiD."
Man, 26, euthanised in Canada because he was diabetic and blind - "A “vulnerable” young man with no terminal illnesses has died by euthanasia in Canada. Kiano Vafaeian, 26, had type 1 diabetes, partial blindness and depression, but was approved for the government euthanasia scheme despite his mother Margaret Marsilla’s protests... British medical bodies have raised significant concerns about the definition of “terminal illness” and safeguards to prevent coercion in the current bill. In November, a poll found more medical professionals oppose than support the draft legislation. The fastest growing category of Canada’s assisted dying is not those with a terminal illness, but those labelled “other”."
HHS official blasts Canada for organ donations from MAID - "Deputy Health and Human Services Secretary Jim O’Neill condemned Canada’s permissive physician-assisted suicide program for ill patients, which he said has crossed ethical boundaries by increasing deceased organ donation rates... O’Neill and Health Resources and Services Administration chief Thomas Engels have said that they are trying to revive trust in the American Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network after multiple troubling reports of organs nearly being harvested from live patients in several states, including Kentucky and New Jersey. But O’Neill said that Canada’s program was uniquely problematic compared to even the most egregious stories in the U.S... The Canadian Medical Association Journal published a paper in 2024 outlining a “substantial increase in deceased donation” in Quebec during the first five years of the MAID program. From 2018 to 2022, the number of deceased donors who died by physician-assisted suicide increased from 4.9% in 2018 to 14% in 2022. A broader study of Canada, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Spain, published in the American Journal of Transplantation in 2022, found that 286 people across the four countries donated their organs after physician-assisted suicide. Nearly half of those donors, 136, came from Canada."
Canada couldn’t treat a sick woman. So it offered her assisted suicide - "Canada’s healthcare system used to be a source of pride for my country. It was regarded as one of the world’s best examples of a publicly-funded insurance system, free at the point of use, ranking highly for accessibility, care, compassion and the treatment of major and minor illnesses. No longer. In 2024, the influential Commonwealth Fund survey placed Canada in seventh place out of ten developed countries, with a particularly poor score for access to care. In January, the Canada-based CD Howe Institute gave the country’s healthcare system an even gloomier diagnosis: it was placed ninth out of 10 countries, with all provinces and territories falling below the international average for overall healthcare performance. Now the world has begun to notice. Story after story has emerged of patients failing to receive the treatment they require. But none is quite so chilling as that of Jolene Van Alstine... Her condition is treatable – said to involve complex surgery to remove her remaining parathyroid gland. But no doctors in Saskatchewan are able to perform it. Her case could have been moved on to a surgeon in a different Canadian province, but she needed to get a referral from an endocrinologist – and none of them are reportedly taking new patients. This is where the story takes a truly sinister turn. Van Alistine sought approval for MAID, or medical assistance in dying. Worse, she was actually approved for medically-assisted suicide. Her husband, Miles Sundeen, told Global News that “she doesn’t want to die. She’s expressed that”, but he understands her position “after watching her suffer for this length of time”. Perhaps aware at how horrific this would look – a woman who says she cannot receive the treatment she requires instead being approved for assisted suicide – the MAID approval has since hit a roadblock. “Ironically that option,” according to Toronto Sun columnist Joe Warmington, “which looked like it could be utilised as early as Jan 7, 2026, has now stalled as a result of Saskatchewan MAID officials telling Jolene that her earlier approval has been pulled because of a bureaucratic error in which just one doctor signed off on it.” (Two independent Canadian medical practitioners are required for mandatory sign-off.)... Cynics have suggested that Beck is using Van Alstine’s illness as a means of attacking socialised medicine in Canada. He doesn’t need to. When a country blindly defends a public healthcare system that won’t do everything in its power to treat a sick patient, and that patient feels they must take the awful option of medically-assisted death, then the system itself is equally sick."
Dei Civitas on X - "Canadian healthcare is so great that a Saskatchewan woman has asked for MAID on January 7. Because no doctor is willing to arrange a surgery to deal with her pain. So an American has to step up and offer to fly this poor woman out of that land of communism and death known as Canada, and get her treatment in the US. Think about this. The Canadian government is willing to kill this woman, but can’t be bothered to heal her."
Kelden Formosa 🍁 on X - "There is a Jewish nursing home in Vancouver that didn't want MAiD performed within its walls because it was traumatizing for the elderly Holocaust survivors who live there. Ellen Wiebe snuck in and performed a MAiD procedure anyways."
Some of Canada’s latest MAID recipients: An obese woman and a grieving widower - "A severely obese woman in her 60s who sought euthanasia due to her “no longer having a will to live” and a widower whose request to have his life ended was mainly driven by emotional distress and grief over his dead spouse are the latest cases to draw concerns that some doctors are taking an overly broad interpretation of the law. The anonymized cases highlighted in the latest report from the Ontario Coroner’s MAID Death Review Committee include people whose conditions were declared “grievous and irremediable” — incurable — and their deaths reasonably foreseeable because they refused all forms of care or had stopped eating and drinking... In all three deaths, hopelessness, isolation and loneliness were driving factors... Mr. C had problems eating, and gait and mobility issues. He felt he couldn’t engage in meaningful hobbies. A neurologist confirmed his condition was incurable, however several members of the 16-member death review committee questioned whether an essential tremor fully met the legislative threshold for a grievous and irremediable condition, noting that an essential tremor “rarely progresses to cause severe disability” or incapacity. Psychological stress can also exacerbate symptoms of essential tremor. Some committee members worried Mr. C’s request for MAID “appeared to be primarily motivated by social withdrawal, grief and hopelessness,” which they believed may have been potentially reversible. “It’s very sad. This poor man. I’m concerned that if he had still been in a relationship his essential tremor would be less bothersome,” said Dr. Ramona Coelho, a family physician and committee member. While he was experiencing trouble eating, his basic activities of daily living weren’t significantly impacted. “These kinds of cases highlight and validate what the disability community has been trying to point out: MAID is a risk to their right to life,” Coelho said. Mrs. A, who had morbid obesity, was isolated and mainly housebound. She had high blood pressure, diabetes, severe shortness of breath, and chronic pain. MAID assessors said her condition could potentially improve with medical treatments such as government-funded bariatric surgery, as well as disability and social supports. However, she refused all care. She hadn’t been to her doctor or diabetes clinic for several years and had stopped taking her medications. Her “re-engagement” with the health system appeared to be primarily for accessing MAID. “The MAID assessors determined her death to be reasonably foreseeable due to Mrs. A’s decision not to pursue additional treatment,” the report reads. But Coelho believes the woman was in a state of neglect. “And that to me, that is patient abandonment. ‘Oh, you want to die? Sure, you can die.’” “I can understand how it can sound like it’s compassionate. It’s what she wants,” Coelho said... “But does that make you eligible for MAID,” Coelho said. “If someone comes to my office and said, ‘I want MAID’ and has had no workup, I will say, ‘I’m here for you, I’d like to explore your suffering. But I cannot say in good faith that you’re eligible for MAID.’” “When we agreed that MAID would be legal, we said we would give it to people who met certain criteria,” Coelho said. Mrs. A also showed signs of catastrophic thinking and “profound psychological and existential suffering.” Both MAID assessors documented that she didn’t have suicidal thoughts. However, loneliness, isolation and psychosocial suffering overlap with suicide risk factors, said psychiatrist Dr. Sonu Gaind, a professor of medicine at the University of Toronto. “We’re clearly providing MAID to some people who have all the risk factors for being suicidal, especially placing those who are lonely and most marginalized at risk,” said Gaind, who does not sit on the death review panel. “And then we’re sanitizing it with false reassurances to society from the white lab coat that the person is not suicidal.” The third case involved Mr. B, a man in his 60s who was living with cerebral palsy in long-term care. He stopped eating and drinking six to eight weeks before his first MAID assessment... Mr. B was experiencing “profound psychosocial suffering and loneliness due to limited social relationships and isolation from the community — a lifelong experience,” according to the report. He worried that he would become more dependent as he got older. Cerebral palsy is an incurable condition, and Mr. B had lost weight and was in an “advanced state of decline,” including signs of kidney failure, because of his decision to stop eating and drinking. However, his suffering was “mainly psychosocial and existentially oriented,” the report reads. Some members worried that “self-facilitated decline” by not eating or drinking, instead of condition-driven decline, could undermine MAID safeguards “and create pathways for circumventing eligibility criteria.”... Of 4,356 reported MAID deaths in Ontario in 2024, most, 88 per cent, met all legislative requirements, according to the report. About 602 required further in-depth review; 281 of those went on to require an investigation."
Damn far right Christian extremists who oppose MAID! They need to be sacked for political interference
Left wingers claim that even one unjustified police shooting is unacceptable because the state is supposed to protect people and is violating its duty. But there's no problem with state killing