L'origine de Bert

Get email updates of new posts:        (Delivered by FeedBurner)

Thursday, August 20, 2026

Links - 20th August 2026 (2 - Prostitution)

Brothel owner shares wildest customer request and most one client spent in one night - "De Noire has seen it all during her time working at the brothel, from drunks running around naked and promising to have sex with all the workers, to two male clients who paid for a threesome but ended up in a twosome, with the female worker left with nothing to do... "I think, the dog fantasy," the brothel manager said confidently, detailing how one of their regular clients, a 'completely normal guy' with a wife, comes in with a dog costume and role-plays as, well, man's best friend.  Rather than having sex in the brothel, 'he's basically just a dog' who gets bossed around by one of the workers, the manager shared.  She explained: "Sometimes there's a customer and she's f***ing him and he's just there staring, like a dog.  "Sometimes he licks the customer, sometimes he chews on the shoes of the customer... Then after the eight hours is done, he just packs up everything and goes home to his wife."  While this might be off-putting for some, people like the man-dog is why De Noire loves her job. She added: "That's why I like to work there, people can get so creative and play around, it's amazing!""

1 woman in custody, 1 other wanted after man allegedly drugged and robbed - "a man contacted a woman on LeoList. Two women then arrived at the victim’s address in the Front Street West and John Street area.  Police allege the man ingested an unknown substance given to him by one of the women and lost consciousness. The women then allegedly stole the man’s personal belongings and fled the residence.  Investigators were able to identify one of the suspects and, on May 28, arrested 27-year-old Natalia Lis Pardinas Da-Hora of Mississauga. She is facing charges of possessing a scheduled substance for trafficking, administering a noxious thing and intent to endanger life, robbery and possession of proceeds of property obtained by crime over $5,000.  Police are still searching for a second woman, who is described as being in her mid-20s, having a thing build with black hair. She was last seen wearing a beige top and bottom. She also has tattoos on both shins and the name ‘Cassie’ under her left chin...   Investigators believe there may also be other victims and are asking them to contact police as well."
Toronto police ID second suspect accused of drugging man - "Police say they continue to search for 19-year-old Sarah Kehttab"

POISONOUS PRETTIES: Oldest profession rife with doping scams | Toronto Sun - “The problem is that the drugs being used by fake escorts are becoming increasingly dangerous.”

Crime against sex workers ‘almost doubles’ since law change | Irish Independent - "Crime against sex workers has almost doubled in the two years since new laws were implemented, campaigners have said.  Ireland adopted the “Nordic Model” on March 27 2017, criminalising the purchase of sex, not the selling of sex, which the Government says is aimed at tackling trafficking and protecting vulnerable people in prostitution.  Sex worker organisations have railed against the change since it was implemented, saying the new laws make workers more vulnerable."
From 2019

I Ditched My Banking Job to Be a Sex Worker - "a Conservative politician dismissed the idea that anyone would willingly become a sex worker.  Speaking to NDP MP Laurel Collins after she urged Parliament to consider decriminalizing sex work, Conservative MP Arnold Viersen said, “I do not think any woman in this country ever chooses this as a job. This is something that they are trafficked into.”... Nearly four years ago, I purposely left a comfortable nine-to-five corporate finance career for the opportunity to be a sex worker. At the time, I had spent six years working in the finance industry, taking on roles in both banking and asset management... While I craved financial stability and security, I also craved wiggle room for personal growth, creativity/expression, and self-care. As a 20-something at the beginning of my career, the two seemed mutually exclusive. If I wanted to advance in my career, I could not count on room for a fulfilling personal life.  I could not plan to travel, take a Spanish class, improve my health and fitness, and finally master the stock market. Hell, I could barely catch up on laundry.  There were so many days at the office I’d catch myself fantasizing about what it might be like to have a random Tuesday afternoon free. How it might feel to have a leisurely lunch, or walk my dogs without having to rush... After only four weeks of dipping my toe into the sex work industry, I quit my job. I was quickly falling in love with my newfound career, and I couldn’t imagine spending another day under fluorescent lighting, wondering what I might do if I had more agency over my time. I discovered that the relationship building model I loved so much in finance, is the absolute core of sex work, but at a much deeper level. Sex workers are emotional labour chameleons. It’s our job to take nervous, vulnerable or stressed individuals and make them relaxed and comfortable. We offer friendship, support and love in a society that’s so clearly over-worked, burnt out, and in need of tenderness.  Sex workers are also full-blown entrepreneurs. So many of the skills that I learned studying business and in my finance roles transferred to sex work. Many of us have created a brand, identified a niche market, designed and directed our own content creation, maintain social media presences, answer all our own emails and customize the experiences we provide to suit our clients. Additionally, many of us do our own web-design, SEO, and monitor our analytics. Not only has sex work allowed me to expand on my administrative skill set in a way that my finance roles couldn’t, it’s taught me how to truly connect with another person on an emotional, spiritual, and physical level. It’s made me into a better partner, and friend, and, because it’s proven to be more lucrative, allowed me the flexibility and freedom to spend more time on myself.  Of course, every job has downsides, and it’d be amiss not to mention them. Not unlike many other careers high in emotional labour (therapists, counsellors, etc.) this kind of work can, at times, be mentally draining. I’m still working on finding balance between providing emotional/physical care to my clients, and recharging my own batteries. The overwhelm of administrative work can also be challenging, and like any other entrepreneurial venture, time management is key. I think collectively, many of us agree that the worst downside is the stigma."

Thread by @FrankDeScushin on Thread Reader App – Thread Reader App - "Seattle sees rising prostitution on their streets. Drugs play a role, but so does the City Council repealing its prostitution loitering law in the name of racial equity after George Floyd died. Because St. George died in Minneapolis there's now more prostitution in Seattle. "The prostitution loitering ordinance has a discriminatory legacy that impacted primarily people of color..." said Councilmember Andrew J. Lewis, a cosponsor of the legislation."

Criminalizing prostitution leads to an increase in cases of rape, study finds - "A recent study published in the Journal of Population Economics sheds light on the unintended consequences of Sweden’s ban on the purchase of sex. The research indicates that the regulation, aimed at curbing prostitution, may have led to an unexpected increase in rape offenses... For his study, Ciacci utilized data from the Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention, spanning from 1997 to 2014. This period allowed for the analysis of crime rates before and after the introduction of Sweden’s sex purchase ban in 1999... The primary outcome of the research suggests that instead of decreasing sex-related offenses, the ban coincided with a substantial increase in the number of reported rape offenses. Specifically, between 1997 and 2014, the study estimates a rise in rape incidents by approximately 44% to 62% following the implementation of the ban... These outcomes challenge the anticipated benefits of criminalizing the purchase of sex as a means to protect individuals from exploitation and reduce sex-related crimes. The study’s implication is that while the intention behind the law is to decrease demand for prostitution and thereby reduce harm, the actual effect might have been to displace behaviors into more harmful and non-consensual acts of sexual violence."
The feminist cope is that prostitution is rape, so this isn't worse

21 charged in sexual-exploitation bust – Brandon Sun - "According to McCallum, police aren’t aware of anyone selling sexual services relating to this investigation being hurt, but that the exchange of money or drugs with someone in a vulnerable position can be considered exploitation"
Car thefts causing concern in Winnipeg
Keeping people safe!

The Secret Life of a Bay Street Hooker - "She is witty, insightful and self-revealing by turns. In other words, good value for money... “You’re retired,” he teases her, and they both have a good laugh. The joke, of course, is that she’s working as they speak. What she doesn’t mention is that she has two children, a boy and a girl under the age of 10, who are at home right now with her ex‑boyfriend (their father)... she decided to go back to school and enrolled in the undergrad program at York, where she majored in history. (She would later complete a master’s degree in the same subject.) Her favourite historical figure was Louis XIV. She loved the stories of life at court in Versailles—the opulence, the decadence, the shameless promiscuity. “I remember reading about the lives of his mistresses and thinking, ‘That’s the life.’ ” Her transformation into “Chloë” did not occur in a seedy nightclub or dark back alley. There were no pimps or oily strip club managers involved in her evolution from good girl to what she calls “the H word” (hooker). Instead, it occurred in a thoughtful, austere sort of way: in a lecture hall at York. It was there that she first encountered the works of Michel Foucault... One regular, an engineer, often books theatre tickets. Another sometimes takes her out to lunch during the week just to catch up (for this, she doesn’t charge). Occasionally, if a client is single, he will even take her as his date to a wedding or a work event. If anyone asks how they met, she responds truthfully: “On the Internet.”  Many keep in touch with her on a daily basis, sending affectionate texts and e-mails and sharing the details of their lives, just as they would in a normal relationship. “They really do think of me as their girlfriend,” Chloë says. “And I see them as the men I’m dating.”... According to Chloë, none of her married clients are interested in leaving their wives. If anything, she says, they are protective of their marriages, preferring a clear-cut arrangement with a hooker to the risk and drama of a full-blown extra-marital affair. “It’s a myth that men talk about their marital problems with escorts,” she says. “If they do talk about their marriages, it’s generally to say that they aren’t having sex at home.” Even if they are, it may not be the kind of sex they’re after. There are some things most men want, she explains, but aren’t comfortable asking of their partners. Asked to elaborate, she looks coy, then lowers her voice and tells me that she does “a lot of anal work” with her clients. This is an erogenous zone most women overlook in men, she says: “I have a little strap-on I sometimes like to put on, and they’re totally into it. I’ve only ever had one client turn me down.”"

High-end escort swallows the hard truth that men are getting worse in bed
To think that men get criticised for not understanding the difference between fantasy and reality

Thread by @moghilemear13 on Thread Reader App – Thread Reader App - "THE MECHANISMS OF WHORING AND GAMBLING《嫖赌机关》
One of the most romantic, charming books I’ve read also has one of the crudest names possible. Written by Shen Hongyu, a late Ming opera singer, only a few copies survive today, preserving a magical moment in Chinese history. It’s a guide to the brothels and casinos of the 江南 region, full of joie de vivre with a clear recognition of the humanity of those on the edges of society, fleshing out a late Ming milieu built on desire, fulfillment  My fave excerpts below w/ Prof. Yuming He’s translations
The book opens with a poem coyly titled 论人该嫖 “One Ought to Whore”, meditating on both the transience of life and the joys of the moment, using classic imagery of brothels and romantic encounters (e.g. willow lanes). Next, the author provides the aspiring patron with Five Do’s and Three Don’ts. It’s not enough to have money - one must also be a caring and charming lover. And even in the world of brothels- loyalty, geniality, and modesty were still the mark of a desired patron. The author goes into details of each of the Do’s and Don’ts - explaining the what, how, and why. Here’s Three, Take Time, and Four, Have Skills. Lovers must invest time into the relationship, and focus on shared pleasure - no place for selfish lovers in the brothel!
Shen next lists ideal characteristics for men and women, many shared. “Morality” is an interesting one to see. These lists share much in common with marriage matchmaking - which isn’t surprising as Shen also favors marrying courtesans. Only "Suzhou style" needs explanation. As one of the centers of high culture in the Ming Dynasty, Suzhou “style”, including mannerisms, habits, and tastes were highly sought after and mimicked by performers all across the country - here Suzhou style is compared to the mythical utopia of the Peach Blossom Spring
After the sections above, the book flips to assorted tips as well as warnings against things such as “ghosting”. The below segment is told from the POV of the woman ghosted, and the man in question is undoubtedly the scoundrel here - an admonition to not act this way. Lastly, some misc. pieces of advice throughout:
LANGUAGE: Shen warns scholar-patrons to avoid the markers of literary Chinese, 之,乎,也, to avoid “scaring the hoes” Additionally, he cautions against repetition - don’t use the same pickup lines with all the girls!
ETIQUETTE: Sex is not something to rush into - everyone should be comfortable and situated first - and let everyone relax a bit before trying for another go!
PARTING AND REUNITING: This one spoke to me personally, having had both experiences. But the emphasis on reuniting after parting is what stood out to me - it’s about how to reunite on good terms too.
MODESTY: Shen warns against trying to impress people with feats of drinking or singing - those with ability will moderate themselves, and won’t rush to be the first to perform.
KNOWING YOUR PARTNER: The theme of shared pleasure is consistent throughout - and Shen reminds the reader here that you have to understand their likes and dislikes first to be a desired lover.
POOR BEHAVIOR: Finally, two cases of frowned-upon behavior - excessive begging/pleading for sexual favors / and those who ghost as soon as they get what they want. Certainly not behaviors praised today either, but delightful to see the same in the Ming.
I hope you enjoyed this window into the milieu of the late Ming - it’s a short but magical time in Chinese history full of joie de vivre and romance.  These passages read to me as shockingly modern, and I hope they can help us reflect on our own hangups in love too. I have the full pdf but translation is slow, I’ve used many of Prof. He’s translations with a few of my own, but as I work through it I’ll add more to this thread.  The most famous copy preserved today was actually taken by the KMT to Taiwan, and sits in Taipei‘s Museum!"
The good professor's book is Home and the World: Editing the "Glorious Ming" in Woodblock-Printed Books of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries

Andy Ngo 🏳️‍🌈 on X - "Seattle — A trans activist and prostitute spoke up against a proposed law banning street prostitution and open drug abuse in certain city areas where the activities have become endemic. The prostitute says the law will “kill” people.  The committee voted to approve the ban, moving the vote to city council next. Leftist protesters tried rioting in response."

Man hires prostitute - and his daughter turns up - "Titus Ncube, a married father-of-three, collapsed to the floor with shock while his daughter, 20, fled the hotel in tears.  Mr Ncube, from Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, said he was having marital problems and decided to rent a room in a local hotel, followed by a prostitute."

Emil O W Kirkegaard on X - "My thanks to Guardian et al for promoting our work on race differences in sexuality. Our survey of prostitutes is getting many more reads now. Currently sitting at the 94th centile of interest score for science papers published that year."
Racial Differences in Sexuality: A Sex Worker Survey - "Racial differences in sexuality are difficult to study due to the privacy of sexual intercourse and the questionable validity of self-reports. We use a novel method to study racial differences: surveying sex workers. We surveyed 129 American female sex workers. We asked them to rate the ethnicities with whom they had had intercourse on thirteen traits and behaviors for five different racial groups: Blacks, Hispanics, Whites, East Asians, Indians, and Jews. The largest reported differences between Blacks and Whites include Blacks having larger penises (d = 1.23, p < .001), that they preferred buttocks over breasts (d = 2.38), and that they preferred doggy-style over missionary (d = 1.42, p < .001). Compared to Blacks, Whites were rated as being particularly interested in kinky sex (d = 0.70, p < .001) and kissing (d = 0.85, p < .001) as well as being faster to ejaculate (d = 0.97, p < .001)."

Herbertstraße - Wikipedia - "In the 1970s, police added barriers and signs advising youths and women against entering: the former for reasons of protection against harmful influences, the latter because prostitutes would actively seek to chase away any women who entered, thus causing trouble"

Japan’s perspective on whether sex work is cheating - "A Japanese TikTok user has perhaps stumbled upon an intriguing cultural norm regarding sex work in his country.  A content creator behind an account called Takashi asked members of the Japanese public the simple question, “Does prostitution count as cheating?”  Granted, while the sample size of about 20 is small, the consensus seems very clear.  It’s a resounding “no” over the course of two videos that canvassed men and women on the moral dilemma... Japan legalised escort services in 1998, although it remains illegal to sell vaginal sex.  Paying for non-coital services or sexual acts not legally defined as “intercourse” is generally allowed."

Nearly half of 130 businesses in Yuhua Place linked to massage & beauty parlours - "According to reports, Yuhua Place has around 130 shops, many of which occupy units on the second floor of shophouses.  Of these, close to half are involved in massage, beauty, or related services.  Retail shops make up about 15 per cent of businesses in the area, while around 10 per cent are food and beverage outlets, according to Shin Min. The remaining units include tuition centres and clinics.  The increase in massage parlours has been observed over the past few years...   Li, the owner of a sundry shop in the area, told Shin Min that there have been occasional disputes between massage workers and housewives."

Students found engaged in prostitution more than three times will face expulsion : r/VietNam - "Here in ‘Nam we believe in third chances…"

No charges in Layton massage parlour leak - "The Ontario Provincial Police aren't laying charges in a leak about the 1996 visit to a massage parlour that found NDP Leader Jack Layton inside.  The police force was investigating the information leak about the 1996 incident at the request of the Toronto Police Service, whose officers raided a suspected bawdy house posing as a massage parlour in 1996.  One of the officers found Layton inside. Layton said he wasn't aware it was a bawdy house and never went back. He was never arrested or charged.  Serving officers are sworn not to leak information to the public. But a retired officer involved in the visit let a reporter see his notebooks from the investigation in the final days of the election campaign that saw the NDP more than double its seats in the House of Commons and become the Official Opposition.  CBC News has learned a private investigator was scouring police and court records the week before the election, looking for information on Layton... Toronto police spokesman Mark Pugash told CBC News that the force is doing an internal review on procedures related to retired officers keeping their police memo books, which are police property.  The notebooks contain officers' notes, suspicions and evidence that, at the time recorded, have not been tested in court.  "We're going to see if any changes [in policy] need to be made," Pugash said.  Pugash told CBC News that a retired officer is beyond the reach of the Ontario Police Services Act, which governs discipline issues. The Toronto police will take no further action, now that the OPP have ruled out any criminal breach of trust.  A provincial police spokesman confirmed to CBC News that it was a former Toronto police officer who gave an interview to a reporter about the raid.  "But the investigation also determined there weren't grounds to lay criminal charges," said spokesman Dave Ross... Both Layton and his wife, NDP MP Olivia Chow, said he did nothing wrong... Chow said in a statement she had been aware of her husband's appointment and the massage clinic was registered with the City of Toronto."
From 2011

Will the BBC apologise for its role in the Jason Arday story?

Will the BBC apologise for its role in the Jason Arday story? | The Spectator

"The BBC’s coverage of the Jason Arday scandal is something of a scandal itself. The corporation spent years uncritically promoting the myth of Arday. Prior to July 2026, the broadcaster produced at least 11 radio programs (totaling nearly six hours of Arday content), four news articles and two TV interviews championing the academic and repeating his false claims.

When the initial story broke about his plagiarism and lies, the BBC doubled down on its defense of the academic. The first article which I would say features real criticism of the former professor was published on August 6, a day after he resigned, more than two weeks after the original Arday exposé was published on Substack and six years after the BBC’s first hagiographic piece about the late academic.
In that time journalists across the world published revelations detailing Arday’s long history of lies and exaggerations, from publications as diverse as the Telegraph and the Daily Mail to the Guardian and the New York Times. For weeks, the BBC ignored them all.
Following Arday’s death, the corporation has returned to its less-than-impartial reporting of the matter. Throughout the saga, the BBC has spent more resources smearing Arday’s exposer, the former Cambridge academic Nathan Cofnas, and participated in a genuine witch hunt against him. Even in articles detailing accusations of plagiarism against Arday, it is clear that the real enemy of the story was the infamous “race realist” Cofnas.
The BBC’s first use of Arday that I can find was from 20 June 2020, when he joined The Moral Maze to discuss racial justice (what else?). Introduced as the Assistant Professor of Sociology at Durham University, Arday argued that teaching children Shakespeare is as important as teaching them about black suffragettes and indigenous figures, and told white people they must acknowledge their privilege.
In November 2020 he was interviewed by Newsnight about racism in academia (you will see a pattern emerge here), and four months later he featured on Radio 4 to discuss “health and social barriers he has faced and overcome throughout his life.”
BBC News interviewed Arday in November 2021, again about racism in academia. He claimed: “If someone asked me what the blueprint is to become an academic, I’d have to say that if you are black or Asian it is ‘how much can you suffer?’ whereas if you are white there is actually a blueprint about getting into academia.”
In February 2023, when Arday was promoted from Durham to become Cambridge’s youngest black professor, the BBC had its first opportunity to fact-check the new professor’s claims about his life story. However, the corporation had found a new star. He ticked all of the BBC’s favorite boxes – diverse, disabled, and a vocal “anti-racist.” Its interview uncritically repeated Arday’s claims that he was nonverbal until age 11, and couldn’t read or write until 18. It featured the near-comically unbelievable line: “Although he could not speak, the young Jason fervently questioned the world around him. ‘Why are some people homeless?’ he remembers wondering. ‘Why is there war?’”
We now have evidence that Arday could speak as a young boy. Two former classmates told the Guardian that they remembered him speaking, joking and singing at primary school. As for his claim that he could not read or write before 18, Arday left secondary school aged 16 with two GCSEs, qualifications that necessarily involve reading and writing.
In his glowing interview, the new professor admitted that in his attempts to become an academic, “everything I submitted got violently rejected.” He continued: “The peer review process was so cruel, it was almost funny.”
Arday’s appointment led to a flood of BBC interviews across its radio, TV and online news arms. Within a six-week period, the corporation interviewed him five times.
The BBC’s next puff piece was a TV interview which repeated Arday’s lies about his youth and featured the now-infamous clip of his boss at Cambridge, Professor Hilary Cremin, holding his hands lovingly. The same claims were repeated in a BBC World Service interview, and on Radio 1Xtra’s If You Don’t Know podcast.
In the latter interview, Arday claimed his mother used music to elicit speech out of him. She apparently played the young boy Enya, and used Gaelic, Greek and Roman mythology to teach him language. A more honest moment came in the interview when the presenter said “I don’t know a lot about sociology,” and Arday replied: “Neither do I.”
Days later the corporation interviewed him again, this time for 44 minutes on the World Service’s Outlook program. Here, Arday recounted another anecdote from his mother. He said that when he was nine (and still nonverbal) she explained the concept of war to him, including “why war happened.” She could see the distress on his face as he tried to comprehend the suffering caused by war. His mother then played him Jimi Hendrix’s “Machine Gun,” which, he said, gave him a “sense of a feeling that people may have felt experiencing war.” He claimed the experience helped him later learn to speak.
Arday told the BBC’s Mobeen Azhar that during his childhood he practiced snooker “seven hours a day for eight years.” Azhar accepted the claim without challenge.
Arday said when he was 18 he set himself a target of raising a million pounds for charity by the time he was 40. “I got to 30, I reached that target through doing a series of crazy marathons, and fundraising events. Subsequently I set up soup kitchens around London, and as we stand I’ve raised just under five million pounds for charity,” Arday said.
There is no evidence for any of this. In 2010, a 24-year-old Arday raised just over £6,000 on Justgiving, and wrote that he aimed to raise “£250,000 before the age of 50.” The Telegraph investigated Arday’s claims about his fundraising, and found no evidence for his grandiose claims.
In September 2023, BBC News ran a piece which should be described more as PR than journalism, describing Arday’s donation of a book advance to neurodivergent charities. Two months later BBC Radio 4 ran yet another piece featuring Arday talking about race.
The BBC’s next programs with Arday were presented by the academic himself. First, he edited the Today program, following in the footsteps of figures including Stephen Hawking, Sir Tim Berners-Lee, Theresa May and Richard Branson. In 2025, he produced four 14-minute segments about loneliness for Radio 4.
This was nothing short of a six-year propaganda campaign by the BBC on Jason Arday’s behalf. Not one critical question was asked by a BBC presenter (the only challenge I heard from anyone was in his very first appearance on the BBC in The Moral Maze, when Melanie Phillips argued with him about BLM), and many of his false claims were repeated as gospel.
The corporation was by no means the only organization to create the Arday legend, but it certainly contributed. The BBC is not a niche outlet: its journalism reaches millions of people in Britain and around the world, with the World Service giving its coverage a truly global audience. One BBC video alone promoting Arday attracted nearly half a million views online. Across the roughly 15 pieces the corporation produced featuring Arday, the cumulative reach will have been substantial, helping to turn an obscure academic into a near-household name.
During my years working for mainstream conservative media outlets, including the Telegraph, the Sun and GB News, nearly all of my work went through an editor or editors, and a lawyer. We would fact-check claims endlessly. The BBC failed to do so.
Meanwhile, in May 2023 emeritus professor at Plymouth Marjon University, David Harris, emailed Arday raising concerns about plagiarism in one of his articles. Cambridge’s youngest black professor responded by accusing Harris of racism and bullying. When Harris raised the issue with another academic, who in turn informed Arday’s boss, Hilary Cremin (of BBC fame), Arday’s article was withdrawn but Cremin said he had the department’s “full support.”...
The BBC responded to Cofnas’s explosive blog about Arday with silence for 11 days. Finally, on 1 August, a headline appeared on BBC News’s website reading: “Cambridge professor at center of plagiarism row defends his work.”
In those 11 days, journalists at national newspapers debunked or seriously challenged a series of claims by Arday, including around his fundraising activities, and that he had run 30 marathons in 35 days, partly with a broken leg. They also raised questions over his account of running 600 miles in six days, which he later revised to 12 days, while WaterAid disputed his claim of carrying out humanitarian work for the charity in South America.
The second paragraph of the BBC’s article was not about Arday, but instead focused on Cofnas’s views on race and the fact he was “sacked from his Cambridge role in 2024,” as if that fact held any relevance. The third paragraph suggested critics of Arday could have “been motivated by racism.” Incredibly, the BBC then repeated Arday’s claims about his childhood yet again without reservation.
The next article was published on 5 August, with its headline: “University of Cambridge professor at center of plagiarism row resigns.” The original version of the article was 600 words long, with 30 percent of it consisting of direct quotes from Arday defending himself. The BBC repeated its attacks on Cofnas in two paragraphs. There was no description of the lies Arday had told about his background.
A day later the BBC updated the piece to feature more quotes and information, including the fact the Met police had investigated a THE journalist “over an allegation of harassment after he emailed questions to Arday.”
In the following week, the BBC published several critical pieces on the now-former professor. Even the Guardian, which is presumably read by many BBC journalists, had published a lengthy investigation into Arday on August 1, casting serious doubt on a number of claims about his career and biography. One BBC piece stated that “Jason Arday’s appointment in 2023 was hailed at the time as a progressive moment,” though it ignored the fact that the Corporation itself had done the hailing.
BBC Verify, a unit dedicated to debunking disinformation, employs around 60 journalists and has an annual budget of more than £3 million ($4 million). Since Nathan Cofnas’s original Substack post, BBC Verify has published investigations into whether Google’s new AI tool could generate misinformation, how heatwaves have altered Britain’s landscape and false claims that sunscreen causes cancer; they failed to investigate Arday.
On 14 August the Metropolitan police announced Jason Arday’s death. We have since seen BBC articles with headlines including: “Calls for public inquiry into Jason Arday ‘witch hunt,’” “Cambridge chancellor criticizes ‘racist feeding frenzy’ around Jason Arday” and “Cambridge vice-chancellor heckled at Arday vigil.”
The first of these articles reverted to the BBC’s pre-August 6 reporting, largely ignoring the mounting evidence that Arday had made false claims about his career and biography, while repeating its attacks on Cofnas. Rather than examining the substance of the claims that had led to Arday’s resignation, the BBC gave prominent space to those accusing the media of having subjected him to a “witch hunt.”
It is ironic that the BBC is now giving so much airtime to those criticizing the media for scrutinizing an academic, when the Corporation itself did so much to put him in the spotlight. The BBC has neither apologized for its role in promoting the Arday myth nor acknowledged its failure to scrutinize his claims more closely. Instead, it has given a platform to attacks on mainstream media outlets that were simply doing their job as journalists.
Jason Arday’s death is a tragedy. As many have pointed out, he was let down by institutions that should never have thrust him into such prominence without properly scrutinizing his claims. The BBC must now confront its own role in that failure."
 
 


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Latest posts (which you might not see on this page)

powered by Blogger | WordPress by Newwpthemes