L'origine de Bert

Get email updates of new posts:        (Delivered by FeedBurner)

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Links - 19th November 2026 (1 - Get Woke, Go Broke: Bioware)

Meme - Salzige Cayde-Herringe @masterwitcher9: "If you think Veilguard is the reason EA closed Bioware, you aren't that bright"
Bob Trabucco @BobTrabucco: "Dragon Age Games: Estimated Sales Revenue, Costs, and Profits (Inflation-Adjusted to ~2026 Dollars)
Origins (2009) *profit*
DA2 (2011) *smaller profit*
Inquisition *big profit*
Veilguard *big loss*"
Exile @LiteraryExile: "Failing to meet sales targets by 50% seems like a pretty big factor."
Lot @Lot_Parker: "Oh yeah, it must've been that other succesful BioWare game they released this decade. Which one was that, again?"
Varrekt @Varrekt: "It was veilgaurd, Andromeda, and anthem that killed them."
Marcos Garm @FenrisGarm: "Cope harder."
Left wing logic: greedy companies will happily lose money unless taken over by even greedier private equity, which destroys companies for funsies

LinaHua on X - "Baldur's Gate 3 gays:
>Look like normal cool people
>Blend in aesthetically with everyone else
>Don't make a big deal out of their relationship
>Don't explain
Went broke cuz too woke gays:
>Look at me, I'm dressed so fabulously
>It's they/them btw
>My favourite position is the Reverse Cowboy
>Let me explain why this important that you understand it
>We are going to have to unpack that"

Mostly Peaceful Michael on X - "The mental gymnastics that Leftists go through to cope with the fact that DEI hiring = garbage woke games = studio closure. The equation is so simple, and it's been repeated *mulitple* times with multiple games and multiple studios.  A large debt can only be covered with a lot of revenue. Veilgard made dick for revenue. You think if Veilgard had made GTA 6 money the studio would have closed? Of course not. The DEI staff of "modern" Bioware didn't have the talent to make Vice City, let alone GTA 6... You're saying two different things. Yes, a bad game is a bad game, and untold thousands of those are made every year by all manner of developers.  And it's possible (though I can't think of an example off hand) that a thoroughly woke, DEI-infested studio could make a good game. The point is that you need a certain critical level of DEI in order for the studio to be cooked in terms of talent available to make a great game. That critical level also happens to be about the point when an intrusive amount of promotion for the game becomes about inclusiveness, and pride flags, and female characters that look like men, etc.  The example of Baldur's Gate 3 is telling because the game had queer stuff in it, but the studio didn't promote the game on that basis, and it was immediately obvious that the talent behind the game was impressive.  So yes, woke BS kills games. But only indirectly as a function of the DEI hiring at the studio hitting a level that basically guarantees bad games going forward.  I know you people hard reset when people tell you DEI is a dumpster fire, but I think I can explain it in a way you'll understand: Let's say the NFL made a reverse-DEI rule that a team had to have at least 3 white players on the field at all times. Zero teams would probably be effected because their existing roster (based on merit) would meet that requirement. What if they raised it to 6? Now you probably affect the lineup of some teams, and they will necessarily have to sign and play some white players that were not good enough to make the lineup on merit. Now what if they raised the requirement to 9? You would see a pretty obvious drop-off in the team's overall on-field talent level. Not because they added white players, but because the white players were not added based on the team's existing merit-based evaluations (whatever those may be for that team).  That's DEI."

LA\/ENDER on X - ""These games aren't for you anymore, if you don't like it don't buy it"
"Ok"
*Several long standing studios collapse*
They got so used to chuds being load bearing pillars that they became arrogant and forgot why they actually needed them in the first place. Assuming they were the ones actually keeping the building upright and those ugly pillars were now just getting in the way and ruining the vibe of the space. So in their arrogance, swimming in the success of their own ego's. They renovated the building to be all hip and new, for their more new and stylish audience. Despite the warnings of the original builders not to remove those pillars. And then the building collapsed on top of them."

BioWare Was Asked to Remove LGBTQ Flag from Canceled Mass Effect Game, Report Says
Clearly, there's nothing wrong with seeing a 21st century flag 8 centuries later

KiTA on X - "There's a theory called Social Gentrification.  There's a long article about it I'll link next but the basic summary is "Nerd things are cool but nerds are still losers."  and  "This nerdy hobby is awesome but who let all these NERDS in?!"  Because Nerd things are cool, they can be farmed for money by selling them to tourists.  But the nerd spaces need to be cleaned up -- gentrified -- for the tourists to feel comfortable.  No one wants to be around nerds, they just want the cool nerdy thing.  The solution is to clean the place up, and that includes driving the nerds who can't clean up -- stop acting nerdy, be polite, be welcoming (subservient) to the tourists -- out.  All so tourists can come in, pretend to play D&D or be a vtuber (vtweeter) or what have you, then move on to the next cool thing.  The name "Tourist" fits very well for many reasons.  But nerds are the socially poor.  They aren't in nerd spaces necessarily because they want to be, but sometimes because they just don't have the social skills required to go anywhere else.  Everyone knows "that guy" who just couldn't cut it outside of a place that ignores the bad hygine, the Aspergers comments, the constant whining about his life, etc.  But at the same time, "that guy" protects everyone else by making the place inhospitable to the kinds of people that would destroy the space for everyone else.  So what happens after a hobby space is socially gentrified?  The tourists move on.  They always do.  And the cleaned up hobby places, either the nerds come back and the place crashes back down to how it can be supported by the remaining nerds, or the nerds don't come back and the hobby place closes down outright, leaving both the nerds that were driven out AND the nerds that weren't out of luck.  The tourists don't care, they were never invested.  "Oh, it's so sad that card shop shut down but it did kinda smell and there was that weird guy from math class there when we went..."  "Oh, 40k is gone?  Darn I used to play that.  Oh well."  "Oh they shut down WOW?  lol I used to play that, I was suuuuch a loser ha ha ha."  We're seeing the a similar thing in the AAA vidya space that happens all the time in other hobby spaces.  It just takes a bit longer cause of inertia.  The tourists that shoved "non binary" into Dragon Age don't care about Dragon Age.  They don't care about Bioware.  They cared about playing pretend gamedev and playing pretend gamer.  They were tourists on both sides of the fence.  The devs that were already there, some were forced out who couldn't keep quiet around the tourists, some managed to keep silent until the end.  The customers who were already invested, they either kept quiet or moved on.  And now the tourists have moved on and the place is gone.  They don't care.  They weren't invested.  The same people who will raise unholy living hell if you try and clean up -- gentrify -- the slums (because welfare addicts in the slums always vote for more welfare, aka, the democrats) won't bat an eye if it's a bunch of straight white male gamers being thrown out of their hobby or white Europeans having their country be ethnically cleansed.  The answer is to be "that guy" whenever you can, making tourists as uncomfortable as possible, no matter what the corporations trying to sell your culture to tourists want.  This is true in hobby spaces, vidya, and countries."

Meme - Chris Avellone @ChrisAvellone: "Based on recent news, if you were rejected from an art position at Obsidian in the past few years, call a lawyer – discrimination in hiring, esp for a Microsoft studio, can ensure you don’t need to apply for a job ever again."
Joebno3 @Joebno_Gaming: "I honestly never would have thought you would call this out."
Chris Avellone @ChrisAvellone: "I had an experience with a BioWare producer who showcased the full extent of their hiring practices, and it's a story for another day - but definitely was cause for a lawsuit."
Iliekturtles @Iliekturtles12: "Is it time for that tale?"
Chris Avellone @ChrisAvellone: "I guess I can say it now - so when applicants would apply to the studio, the producer would go through their LinkedIn to see what posts they liked, and if he disagreed with their political/social Like, he'd advocate not to hire them based on their Like. Now, there's times where that's appropriate (you don't want to hire someone who favors not working in teams, or hates game development, or is using your studio as a stepping stone to another), but in this case, it didn't feel appropriate. Not approving someone because of lack of skill or experience, sure but I don't expect everyone to have the same political viewpoint as I do, nor do they have to have the same viewpoint to work well together on a game. Some of my friends have radically different views than I do, but I've worked alongside them on games and trust them and their skills. In general, I don't discuss politics or bring politics into game development: I want to focus on the game as entertainment and how to improve the player's experience and I want the most skilled person doing the job and making it happen."
What an ignorant Nazi! Clearly, he has no idea what working on video games is like

SirD on X - "You guys say the darndest things. Half of the woke elements in BG3, none of which made the game better btw, were added in by request long after the game was in early-access, and they were completely avoidable.  What woke elements had were mostly inconsequential and countered by anti-woke elements. It was edgy, at times politically incorrect, it had attractive female characters with full on sex and nudity, it let players straight up murder any party member or character they didn't like... its narrative was wholly driven by the player.  The degree to which something is woke exists on a spectrum. No one is arguing that the moment a pronoun selector lands in a game, it turns to ash and is unplayable. We're explaining that left-wing politicization, aka "making games woke," lessens their quality. The more woke the game, the lesser its quality. Games that are "super woke" will have dogshit characters and stories, because their existence will be political and they'll be more of a checklist than a genuine creative decision.  Not a complicated subject. You guys are just incapable of being honest."

SirD on X - "Leftists just can't stop lying/trying to claim everything as "woke."
"Dragon Age Origins is like, super woke actually!"
Meanwhile, Dragon Age Origins:
> Has the most bro character ever in Alistair.
> Has a hot mage who walks around with her tits halfway out.
> Has a Qunari who tells you that bitches aren't warriors.
> Lets you literally backhand the bossy woman for mouthing off.
> Lets you side with the Templars, who are literally just Mage oppressors.
> Is a complete and utter straight male-centric power fantasy from top to bottom.
"b-b-b-but there's a minor NPC whose gender is ambiguous who has 10 minutes total screentime! And they added a gay character later in the expansion!""
LearningTheLaw on X - "They poisoned the waters for genuinely artistic creations.  Most of the people they call “chuds” have probably seen or consumed gender ambiguous designs in Japanese games for years, and nobody cared because, when those designs are done properly, they fit naturally into the world building.  Look at JoJo characters. They can be flamboyant, ambiguous, masculine, brave, and completely unforgettable without constantly screaming, “Pick me.”  That’s why their whole cultural battle is disingenuous and evil. They act like people can’t tell the difference between a genuine artistic decision and a design that is ideologically driven."
One Eyed Jack Gaming on X - "It's not the fact that DA had gays in it originally.  It's the fact that since GamerGate, it has become compulsory to include an excess of queer themes in everything and be obnoxious about it.  Look at the game Days Gone. I love that game. It has a lesbian mixed raced duo. But you know what that couple doesn't do? Lecture about how gay they are.  Would I prefer gays not be included generally speaking? Yes. But if it must be done, Days Gone is how you do it."the

Thread by @Sir_Dammed on Thread Reader App – Thread Reader App - ""Private equity killed Dragon Age!"  Private equity didn't make the Dragon Age developers turn Veilguard into a gigawoke, gender non-conformist trauma fantasy that we all laughed at instead of buying.  "Oh yeah? You think "woke" is disliked? Then what about Baldur's Gate 3?!"
"The game has trans characters!"  A trans character who at least half of players won't even encounter tied to Shadowheart's storyline, that you meet and briefly interact with.
"It has gay characters!" as does nearly every other western RPG ever made. Never been a problem until leftists politicized game development and turned up the dial to 1000 on gay shit, for political reasons, mostly driven by their obsession with diversity and inclusion.
"It lets you select pronouns and make non-binary characters!" see screenshots linked above.
"So something isn't woke if you like it or it's a good game??"
Not what anyone is saying, goofballs. A game can have "woke elements" like BG3 does. That doesn't make the entire thing woke. Video games have always been diverse. Video games have always catered to numerous demographics, not just 1 specific group of people.  What separates something that is woke, from something that is not woke, is whether or not it was created with consumers in mind.  Woke games are created in spite of the preferences of the majority straight male consumer base. Woke developers create with an agenda, rather than focusing primarily on entertainment/fun. Non-woke games are created for straight men, even if they have elements that were implemented which appeal to others. BG3 is an example of a game that overwhelmingly caters to straight men, and that focused primarily on entertainment/fun.
"So if a game is created for gay people, it's woke and shouldn't be allowed?!"
If a game is created for gay, trans, non-binary, whoever... there's literally nothing wrong with this. The problem is not making games for people outside of straight men.  The problem is doing so while pretending that nothing has changed, and deceptively marketing them. If you make a game for the queers, and you clearly market it as a game made for queers... none of us are going to have a problem with that.  Sure, we're not going to buy it because it's not for us.  Instead, you guys constantly coopt already established franchises, that already have a set audience of predominantly straight men, change it/add a bunch of gay shit into it, try to hide it... and then you act shocked and awed when we find out and refuse to buy it.
"Why are you having a conversation with yourself?! You're fighting ghosts to live out your chud fantasy!" Everything I quoted is something that has unironically been said to me/argued by leftists pretending they don't know what woke is, or why we dislike it. "
Left wingers love erecting straw men, then accusing others of hypocrisy for not adhering to them

SirD on X - ""Um equity isn't a subversion of merit. You can have both merit and DEI, guys."––
Merit completely eradicates/eliminates the need to look at race, sexuality, or gender... because you literally just hire the single MOST qualified person, REGARDLESS of those traits. It is extremely rare that two individuals have *identical* education, experience, and qualifications.  Diversity, equity, and inclusion = factoring race, gender, and sexuality into the hiring process, while assuming certain groups (ex: straight men) are more "privileged/advantaged" than others. Then adjusting your hiring standards accordingly. In other words, yes, DEI eradicates merit.   This is how these subversive leftists got their "foot in the door" of major studios, companies that were literally built by chuds, before declaring "no chuds allowed.""
Left wing logic: DEI is needed to get the best talent, and the reason why overwhelming white male products succeeded in the past but DEI-ed products fail today despite DEI getting you the best talent is because of EA/private equity/YouTubers brainwashing the audience into not buying good products

Nick Calandra on X - "Weird, I guess the people actually sad about BioWare closing aren’t their fans, only you are. Interesting."
SirD on X - "Yes Nick, that is exactly the point.  You guys aren't sad BioWare closed "because you're a fan." You're sad that we have yet another point in the long pattern which proves "nobody likes your shit woke games."  BioWare's fans ARE happy it closed. Want to know why? It's because the company we loved was taken over by weird, self-absorbed left-wing activists wearing game developer skin-suits.   They proceeded to take a franchise consisting of politically incorrect, male power-fantasy games... games that overwhelmingly appealed to and were made for straight men... and twist/contort said franchise into a weird, insufferable gender non-conformist trauma fantasy layered with not so thinly veiled propaganda.  Hence why nobody bought it. Hope this helps."

Nick Calandra on X - "Every time I ask a “chud” why they don’t make their own games, especially cause they outnumber all of us apparently, they always come back with excuses. Apparently they can’t just team up, start prototyping a game, and see if the market wants what they’re putting out."
SirD on X - ""Chuds" built nearly every single video game franchise and IP that you absolute RETARDS are currently destroying, after you used political activism to subvert merit and herald equity & inclusion, which was the only way you could even get jobs/be hired.  Halo, Mass Effect, Dragon Age, Baldur's Gate, The Witcher, Gears of War, The Last of Us, God of War, Neverwinter, Diablo, Warcraft, Starcraft, Age of Empires, Fallout, Divinity, Fallout, Elder Scrolls, KOTOR, Runescape, Minecraft, Borderlands, Call of Duty, Half-Life, Counter-Strike, Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead Redemption, Batman Arkham, Spider-Man, Uncharted, Hitman, Red Alert, Deus Ex...  Every single fucking ONE of these legendary western IPs started with, overwhelmingly: predominantly straight, predominantly white nerds and dude-bros who at the time didn't give a single fuck about "equiTY anD inClusiON." And this is JUST the western side of the games industry. We all know how much you guys hate Japan because it's a "chud country," and its games industry is ALSO predominantly straight nerds and dudebros with overwhelmingly traditional and Christian-aligned values.  Holy shit this guy is unbelievably retarded. This might even be the most retarded post I've ever seen on Twitter."

Meme - Jonathan Choe @choeshow: "GO WOKE: According to Melissa Boone's bio, she joined Xbox research in 2015. She also leads research in diversity, inclusion, and accessibility across Xbox’s games and experiences, with a focus on making Xbox a place where everyone has fun!
GO BROKE: "The Halo franchise reached its peak with Halo 3 and has been in a downward spiral since, with Halo Infinite losing 98% of its player base. Halo's shift away from its traditional audience and embrace of activist themes has contributed to the brand's loss of appeal and cultural relevance."-ClownfishTV"
End Wokeness @EndWokeness: "This is who Microsoft just chose to put in charge of their Halo franchise. RIP."
"Hi! Currently I'm the chief of staff at Halo St running of our studio; it includes a little bit the stewards of the Halo franchise. My role is to ensure the smooth rything - I'm a problem-solver, a process-builder, a strategic thinker, an executor, an integrator, communicator and an advisor. Basically this is the best job ever for someone with a lot of interests who likes to stay BUSY (and possesses a healthy passion for military science fiction games and lore)..."

Meme - "Woohoo! Bioware is DEAD!"
"How dare you! Don't you know that people lost their jobs??"
"You mean the hand selected liberal weirdos that were getting a salary to destroy my hobby? What did you THINK I was celebrating?"

Meme - *Mass Effect Logo*
"Mass Layoffs"

Meme - "SUCCESS *Aion 2*
Steam charts
130,930 players right now
383,176 24-hour peak
397,905 all-time peak 2 days ago
*attractive character*
FAIL *Dragon Age The Veilguard*
Steam charts
298 players right now
588 24-hour peak
89,418 all-time peak 1.9 years ago
*unattractive character*"

Meme - LA\/ENDER @LavenderGhast: ""These games aren't for you anymore, if you don't like it don't buy it"
"Ok"
*Several long standing studios collapse*"
Cardinalboy @Cardinalboy3: "Fuck ass mentality"
Nicholas @Nicholasli0: "Good luck with that bitch. Cause we liberals control most western nations studio and so good the fuck luck on driving us out."
Vee @not_vee: "You control the production but not the consumption, idiot. We can stay disinterested longer than your idiots can stay solvent."

Meme - packergirl @p9cker_girl: "Bloomberg Reporter Jason Schreier "Go woke, go bro- err, top the charts. I actually don't like [Dragon Age: The Veilguard] very much, but I do like seeing you chuds get dunked on""
Jason Schreier: "Go woke, go bro- err, top the charts."
Mr. Clown: "There's no way you genuinely like this turd."
Jason Schreier: "I actually don't like the game very much, but I do like seeing you chuds dunked on"
Game "journalists" hate their audience

Meme - Young Gamora: "DID YOU 'OWN THE CHUDS?'"
Bioware (Thanos): "Yes"
Young Gamora: "WHAT DID IT COST?"
Bioware (Thanos): "Everything"

Dragon Age maestro says EA always spoke about a hypothetical 'nerd cave' full of diehard RPG fans who would "always show up," so you "didn't have to try and appeal to them" - "A Dragon Age veteran says EA liked to refer to a "cave" where RPG fans who could be trusted to buy anything the genre threw at them would dwell.  Speaking to GamesRadar+, BioWare veteran David Gaider explained that before he left BioWare, his tastes had become somewhat "old-fashioned" in EA's eyes. "I was very vocal on the Dragon Age team," he says. "I was always trying to push it to our traditional mechanics. And that wasn't very welcome in the EA sphere."  He says that EA considered those mechanics - the kind that shaped games like Dragon Age: Origins - to be "slow and cumbersome," rather than the "action-y and slick" presentation that the studio was being pushed toward. That meant that Gaider's views "were often not very welcome" despite his long tenure at the studio and work on many of its most famous RPGs.  That's partly because, he says, EA didn't think the traditional RPG audience was one that was worth focusing on. He claims that the overseers referred to those mechanics as being "'in the cave'". The cave, he explains, "was where nerds went. The nerds were in the cave. You made an RPG and the nerds in the cave would always show up for an RPG, because it was an RPG." That devotion to their chosen genre, in EA's eyes, meant that "you didn't have to worry" about the nerds. "You didn't have to try and appeal to them. You had to worry about the people who weren't in the cave, which was the audience we actually wanted, which was much larger.""
Aurondarklord yearns for Malfoid on X - "I've been saying for years that this belief is widespread in entertainment industries.  Basically taking traditional white male nerds for granted and assuming every other group can be catered to over us because we're just addicts who'll buy it anyway.  We keep proving that assumption wrong by refusing to show up when we are actively not catered to, but these companies still seem to believe it."
Damn EA killing Bioware by making it insert wokeness everywhere!

Daniel Friedman on X - "If you look at the top YouTube videos about successful games like "Ocarina of Time: Remake" or "Elden Ring," you'll see players playing and enjoying the game, showing off cool boss fights or detailing how to find secrets. Of the 10 most-viewed YouTube videos about "Dragon Age: The Veilguard," four are promotional content from BioWare, three are Asmongold videos ripping on the game's extensive trans and nonbinary content, one is the viral and extremely negative Skill Up review that rips the game's simplified mechanics and one is from Dunkey making fun of the game's repetitive exposition and bad writing."

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Links - 18th November 2026 (2 - Palestine/Middle East Peace [including Ed Sheeran])

The humbling of Ed Sheeran is a disaster for the music industry - "If Ed Sheeran can be made to wonder – in front of 50,000 people – whether he wants to remain an artist any more, the music industry has a far bigger problem than a support act using a superstar’s platform to propel his political cause.  Writing from Britain and America, we both recognise what happened to Sheeran. One of us is a British choreographer who lost the company she founded after saying, in a private conversation, that women are real. She now co-leads Freedom in the Arts, which supports artists facing bullying and censorship. The other is a Scottish Jewish journalist, former deputy editor of the NME and long-time Los Angeles resident, who has experienced professional isolation for speaking about anti-Semitism.  This could be the wake-up call the industry needs, or the start of a descent into madness in which all art becomes political because even trying to remain outside politics is treated as a political offence. The public can be forgiven for feeling confused. Macklemore, the rapper, used his support slot on Sheeran’s American tour to deliver political speeches, perform Hind’s Hall, a pro-Palestinian protest song, and show images from Gaza. US stadium owners then refused to host him and the promoter removed him. Other performers withdrew in solidarity, while boycott and refund demands turned towards Sheeran, who later felt compelled to set out his own position on the conflict in Gaza.  Macklemore’s supporters claimed censorship. But the claim that he has been silenced looks difficult to sustain. He has announced an international Free Palestine arena tour, including a headline show at Wembley Arena. It is a curious form of cancellation that leads within weeks to a Wembley booking, while the artist whose platform was commandeered is left to absorb the damage.  So who, exactly, is making the rules?... The rules are being improvised by whichever faction can create the greatest reputational threat.  Within the entertainment industry, the system has hardened. Everyone is watching everyone: the publicist watching a reaction to the artist; the manager watching the publicist; the label watching the manager, and so on. If one person becomes toxic, the danger travels across the chain.  Sheeran’s fame did not protect him; it made him a valuable trophy. His public ordeal warns less powerful performers what resistance might cost them. Here is the sucker punch: every artist is exposed. Political artists risk crossing shifting boundaries; apolitical artists are told silence is complicity. Those who acknowledge suffering without taking the “acceptable” position are labelled cowards, while those who speak may lose venues or sponsors. There is simply no safe answer.  Through Freedom in the Arts, we see what happens below celebrity level. Work disappears, invitations stop arriving, collaborators withdraw and artists censor themselves before anyone openly threatens them. If Sheeran’s future in music can be thrown into question, imagine the position of a young performer with no financial cushion or powerful agent... Sheeran’s beliefs were put on trial. He opened his Philadelphia show with a statement describing the Hamas attack on Israel, including the Nova music festival, as horrific, and saying that it compounded “centuries of Jewish pain”. He also called what was happening in Gaza catastrophic, unjustifiable and disproportionate, and spoke about injustice in the West Bank. It certainly did not satisfy his critics. Charlotte Church accused him of choosing capitalism over doing the right thing, as though acknowledging Jewish suffering alongside Palestinian suffering were a moral failure.  The pressure to Sheeran reflects a wider pattern that Freedom in the Arts has documented across the cultural sector: “Zionist” becomes a contaminating label and artists are required to denounce Israel, or those associated with it, before they are permitted to belong.  This is why no statement from Sheeran could ever have been enough. A public struggle session is not designed to discover what someone believes, but to isolate, humiliate and degrade them until they recite the required position. The industry must stop rewarding this behaviour. Freedom in the Arts has produced practical guidance for artists, agents and venues, but the principle is simple: do not rush into a panic-stricken statement simply because social media demands one... No state ministry is imposing this political code. The industry is doing it to itself and artists are doing it to one another. Unless it wakes up, the young musician who wants to explore the boundaries of expression will learn instead to make bland, safe work and live in fear of mistakes. We will not merely lose freedom of speech. We will lose the independence and uncertainty from which art is made."
This doesn't stop terrorism supporters from pretending they are brave, oppressed and powerless

Thread by @LilyN_1 on Thread Reader App – Thread Reader App - "I think the Ed Sheeran and Macklemore situation is a lot more complicated than simply asking, “Who was right?”  And personally, my issue isn’t even with Macklemore having a political position.  He is completely entitled to his beliefs and to use his own platform to speak about them.  My issue is that this was Ed Sheeran’s tour.  When you’re appearing as a supporting artist on someone else’s tour, I think there’s a basic level of professional courtesy involved.  If you’re planning to turn part of your set into a political statement about an extremely sensitive and divisive subject, I feel like that is something you discuss with the person whose tour you’re on beforehand.  Not because they have the right to control your beliefs.  Not because you need their permission to have an opinion.  But because what you say on that stage doesn’t happen in isolation. It can affect the tour, the venues, the promoters, the other artists and ultimately the person whose name is attached to the entire thing.  And that’s exactly what happened here.  Macklemore made his pro-Palestinian remarks during his opening performance, including introducing “Hind’s Hall” with a call to “Free Palestine.” The controversy subsequently led venues and promoters to object, and Macklemore was removed from the remaining dates. Sheeran later said that the removal was the promoter’s decision, not his.  That’s why I think Macklemore put Ed in an incredibly difficult position. These two aren’t strangers either. Macklemore has described Ed as a longtime friend and “brother,” while Ed said Macklemore had asked to join the tour and that he respected him as an artist. If that’s your friend, and you’re joining his tour, I’d expect that conversation to happen before the microphone is in your hand.  You can absolutely stand for something.  You can disagree with your friend.  You can have convictions that are completely different from his.  But when you’re standing on someone else’s stage, representing part of their production, I think you owe them enough respect to say, “This is what I intend to do. Are we okay with this?”  To me, that’s not censorship.  That’s consideration.  Macklemore can say whatever he wants on his own tour. But when you’re a guest on somebody else’s, your freedom to speak doesn’t erase your responsibility to consider the person who gave you the platform in the first place. And that’s the part of this situation I struggle with.  Not the politics.  The friendship. The courtesy. And the professional responsibility."

Melissa Chen on X - "Ed’s always had the reputation of being one of the decent ones. The rare guy in the music industry who actually lifts people up, nurtures them and genuinely sees music as a way to inspire and bring people together. His entire vibe is wholesome and earnest, the kind of guy who believes in the power of love and all that (it’s way too kumbaya and saccharine for my tastes).   Which is what makes this whole affair so grim.   Because he should be the last person to receive so much hate and vitriol.   When he says he’s lost friends over this, the thing that jumps out to me is the really bad behavior of his “friends” in the music industry.   You know, the ones he actually invited out on his massive tour. Macklemore and the other opening acts get bigger crowds, bigger paydays and a platform most of them wouldn’t have had on their own.   First, Macklemore used Ed’s stage to make the night all about his own cause. Bro you’re the opening act, nobody is paying for those tickets to see you.   Second, after Robert Kraft and the other stadium owners made it clear the shows weren’t happening with Macklemore on the bill, what did he do? He threw his “friend” under the bus.   The decent move would’ve been for Macklemore to say to the public, “this wasn’t Ed’s fault. Don’t turn him into the villain.”  Instead he’s watched Ed take every arrow on social media and get churned through a full-blown media storm. He lets the climate in which activists hysterically accuse Ed of being complicit in genocide and post absurd cartoons of him personally shooting a Palestinian kid with an RPG fester and bloom.   There were lots of things Macklemore could’ve said to take some of the heat off the man who actually put him on that stage. But he didn’t.   Neither did the other openers who walked. Instead they framed it as principle and solidarity. From the outside it just looks like they took the opportunity, cashed the goodwill, and then left Ed trying to figure out how to keep the tour alive for hundreds of thousands of ticket-holders and the crew who actually depend on the tour to get paid. Ed is the one who took all the risk after all.  This dynamic reminds me of those child actors who built careers off @jk_rowling ’s work and then publicly disowned her the second her views became inconvenient. These are not good people and they don’t know gratitude.   Ed’s finding out, the hard way, just how many shitty people were around him.   It’s a terrible experience to go through but in the long run, he would be all the wiser for it"

Charlie Walsham on X - "Poor Ed hasn’t realised yet that it doesn’t matter what he says, how reasonable he is, or how even-handed he tries to be. In fact, being even-handed is precisely what is unacceptable to the people who have come after him.  The struggle session they’ve put him through has to end with complete capitulation: he must parrot the progressive tribe’s approved narrative. Nuance isn’t permitted. He has to show a level of desperate contrition that would strip him of all dignity. Only then will the “kind” and “tolerant” mob move on to their next target.  And this is the thing: you may feel strongly about Israel’s actions in Gaza. You may even think the response to October 7 has been so disproportionate it’s inhuman. But if you actually believe in humanity do not want to align yourself with people who decide what is right and wrong, what can and cannot be said, and even what reality is, based on their own narrow ideology - and then demand that everyone else goes along with it.  They don’t have enough power to literally force people to comply. But the instinct is authoritarian: dissent is not something to debate, but something to punish.  We’ve seen that instinct play out throughout history. And not in a good way.  Ed isn’t stupid, and I suspect eventually he’ll realise what sort of people he is dealing with.  What he said was perfectly reasonable. It’s his opinion. His critics are entitled to disagree with him. What is unreasonable is the insistence that disagreement itself is unacceptable.  And when the thought-police who have been criticising Ed Sheeran most vocally talk endlessly about fascism, the irony is hard to miss."

Campaign for Media Standards on X - "BBC Radio 4’s news flagship show this morning cut out Ed Sheeran’s condemnation of 7 October, leaving listeners with only his words on Gaza. Why did the BBC choose to make such a biased editorial call?"
Stop the Hate - Leeds on X - "The BBC cancelled the Jewish side of Ed Sheeran's comments on why he didn't want to get drawn into politics. This is our national 'unbiased' media service. A disservice to both Sheeran and Jewish people as well as to Britain."

Eve Barlow on X - "The whiplash from Ed Sheeran is real because he’s going thru it in real time.   The suddenness of the floor falling out from under you. The beginning of questioning an ideology that’s been shoved down your throat. The noticing of unhinged behavior from people you thought you’d known for years. The fear of not knowing about a situation you’re being pressurised to have an opinion on. The inability to know your own integrity because you can’t trust anything you’re being told. The kneejerk desperation to deescalate and appease everyone and no one at the same time. The futility of all of it. The existential dread that your life as you knew it is over and will never be the same again. The ego death and the fragile rebirth. The not knowing who you are any more or why it happened. The immediate loss of safety in the home you built for yourself and your community.   You are watching something so many of us have experienced happen on a very large stage under a microscope right now. Hopefully it will help you see the total lack of humanity in the “humanitarian” cause."

Meghan Elinor on X - "This has to be one of the dumbest controversies on the internet this week…  Ed Sheeran vs Macklemore.  People bought tickets to hear Ed Sheeran. Not to get lectured by the opener.  Macklemore had two nights at MetLife and used them to turn Ed’s show into his own political event. “Free Palestine,” the protest song, Gaza footage on the screens. That’s not bravery. That’s taking someone else’s stage and making it about you.  And let’s be real about whose stage it was. Ed Sheeran is one of the biggest pop artists alive. Stadiums. Worldwide tours. Songs that actually last. Macklemore had a huge run over a decade ago and has been chasing relevance ever since. That’s why he was opening, not headlining. He didn’t build this tour. He borrowed it.  Then the venues said they wouldn’t host the dates if he stayed on. Kraft and the other owners aren’t required to hand him a microphone. The promoter isn’t required to risk canceling shows and wrecking it for hundreds of thousands of people who paid to Sheeran. He said it wasn’t even his decision. He also said he wasn’t going to blow up the tour, the crew, and the fans because his opener wanted a campaign stop.  That’s not “silence.” That’s not complicity. That’s the headliner refusing to let a support act tank the whole run.  Now the left is doing what it always does. Instant outrage. Instant boycotts. Instant “Ed Sheeran is complicit” posts from people who were never going to that show anyway. It’s performative. It’s the same woke script: hijack something normal, demand everyone clap, then scream when the adults in the room say no.  Macklemore can say whatever he wants on his own stage. He doesn’t get Ed Sheeran’s audience by default. The other openers walking off in solidarity can do that too. Fine. Don’t pretend Sheeran is the villain for keeping a concert a concert.  If you want a rally, throw your own. Don’t crash a Loop Tour date and then act shocked when the venues shut it down."

Macklemore on X - "What happened to me is bigger than one artist or one stage. When the billionaire class can decide which voices are allowed on stage and which ones are too dangerous to hear, everyone should be paying attention. So we're going on tour. All proceeds will benefit organizations supporting the Palestinian people and movement. Sign up at http://macklemore.com"
S k y on X - "You know how long it takes to coordinate a single show???? Dude had a full tour ready to go. Knew exactly what he was doing and fucked over Ed Sheeran to do it. What a piece of shit"
Not surprising that terrorism supporters are disgusting

Now the music industry is against cancel culture? - "Is Ed Sheeran the only ginger not to have converted to Islam? The multi-billion-streaming folk star seems to have an immunity to the Gaza-tardation infecting the music industry. Fellow-ginger Macklemore, by contrast, is suffering stage-four Israel Derangement Syndrome. The pop-rapper’s affliction began years ago with Jew-costumes and Sieg Heils. This week it got him sacked from Sheeran’s Loop Tour. Rather predictably, Macklemore, real name Benjamin Haggerty, has the support of his Generation Gaza music peers. Solidarity came from fellow support acts on the tour, Aaron Rowe, Lukas Graham, and Billie Eilish’s brother Finneas. The latter is also ginger. This may help explain things. Even Sheeran’s actual backing band – Beoga – have pulled out of the stadium run. Beoga, like Aaron Rowe, are from Ireland, perhaps the nation with the highest per capita infection rate of Israel Derangement Syndrome. And though they may not be openly ginger, their Irish heritage makes them likely carriers of the regressive red gene...  For the English mega-star it’s lose-lose. “I am not complicit. Those who come to my shows do not expect a political forum.” The Sheeran dog-pile of the deranged far-left activists who dominate music has expanded to include politician AOC, mentally disabled omni-cause campaigner Greta Thunberg, and Hacks actress Hannah Einbinder, who noted “as a ginger” she hoped he got a “really bad sunburn.”... Even if it were possible to keep the Israel-bashing rapper on the tour – Sheeran would have to face the continued backlash of fans, especially Jewish fans, who may or may not enjoy being accused of blood libel out at a pop concert.  Macklemore’s blood libel is nothing new. He was swept up in the Islamist propaganda from the start of the Israel–Hamas war. Before Israel had even begun their response to the horrors of 7 October he was already describing it as an “unfolding genocide”. Meanwhile ignoring Hamas’s responsibility as they kept those hostages hidden away in the labyrinth below the sand. Herein lies the problem. Macklemore’s acute mental afflictions were known long before he was booked onto Sheeran’s mega-tour. If Kraft had objections, they should’ve been made before the tour was announced. Even Sheeran should’ve known better."

Meme - "Macklemore: I just care about Palestinians
Also Macklemore: *Jewish prosthetics with huge nose*"

Meme - Mehdi Hasan @mehdirhasan: "This is insane. The so-called land of the free."
Pop Base @PopBase: "Promoters have pulled Macklemore from Ed Sheeran's tour after he called for a "Free Palestine" on stage: "We have been notified by venues on the upcoming U.S. tour dates that they will not allow a concert to take place with Macklemore on the lineup"..."
Mehdi Hasan @mehdirhasan: ""Free speech does not mean freedom to speak without consequence." Yes, exactly! This this this!"
Mark Joseph Stern is on parent...: "Criticism is not censorship or cancellation. Free speech does not mean freedom to speak without consequence. Free association entails the freedom to disassociate with speech you find objectionable. Reject these principles and the c..."

Meme - hilalove @hilalove_x: "Antizionists maintain that antizionism is distinct from antisemitism while repeatedly showing us they are in fact the same fucking thing."
Dr.Sam Youssef Ph.D.,Ph.D.,...: "Ed Sheeran announces Benjamin Netanyahu as the new opener for his tour" *Ed Sheeran as The Happy Merchant*

Saturday Night Live UK: comedy for NPCs - spiked - "Ania Magliano told viewers that Macklemore had been thrown off ‘at the insistence of pro-Israel billionaire Robert Kraft’. Paddy Young called Kraft a ‘wealthy corpse-maxxer’. The following week, guest host Amelia Dimoldenberg stood on the same stage and called Sheeran ‘a world-famous, red-headed puppet with a hand up his arse telling him what to say’. And whose arm is it controlling Ed Sheeran’s every move? The same one it’s been for the best part of 900 years... Plagues, wars, stock markets, pop tours, transvestites. If there’s devilment afoot, you can be sure a Jew is behind it. You’d think a hatred from the time doctors worked with leeches would have exhausted itself by now, but no. It seems as if humans come with anti-Semitism software pre-installed, like McAfee LiveSafe...  This is where UK comedy has ended up. You can use ‘gay’ as a punchline, as long as it’s aimed at a ‘Nazi’, while you yourself are engaged in spreading blood libels against Jews. The puppet joke about Sheeran is almost identical in form. Sheeran’s humiliation is that another man is inside him, working him, and that the man is a Jewish billionaire. So the show reaches for homosexuality, twice, as the worst thing it can say about a man. Is it for gay people or against them? Is it against National Socialism or for it? I don’t think the people who wrote it could tell you. But the image of Sheeran on a Jewish billionaire’s hand suggests they would have prospered as German political cartoonists in 1936...  The people in that studio are what I call NPCs. They go along with whatever the mood is without ever examining it. ‘Trans women are women.’ ‘From the river to the sea.’ ‘Genocide.’ NPCs don’t form opinions; they memorise them. And SNL UK is written for people who clap when they hear one read back to them... that’s what stays with me about these people. They think of themselves as good. Yet they’ll turn on their friends, on the people who helped make them famous, and in the end on a whole people, as long as the room is going the same way. I know how easy it is for them, because I watched most of an industry do it to me. Hardly any of them thought they were being cruel. They thought they were on the right side, and one or two probably thought they were being brave. The career benefits were a coincidence.  Back on 19 September, Young closed the Sheeran item with this: ‘Say what you want about Ed, but he’s always been a passionate advocate of causes that are allowed.’ You have to admire the hypocrisy. The show will do Netanyahu, Tommo, Zuckerberg and Prince Andrew all day long. It will not do anything to address the biggest social change since women got the vote: trans ideology. It will not do Isla Bryson, the double rapist who was sent to a women’s prison after deciding he was a woman. It will not do Sandie Peggie, the nurse in Fife who was suspended after objecting to getting changed in front of a male doctor. There’s comedy in all of it, surreal, horrible comedy, but the producers of SNL UK will never touch any of it, because it’s not allowed. What a confused mess it all is. I genuinely feel for anyone trying to be funny right now. But the fashionable hatred of the day should be the obvious target for any comic with nerve, and today that hatred is anti-Semitism. Joining in takes no courage and no imagination. The world has quite enough of it already, and I have no sympathy for opportunistic mediocrities who use the moment to add to it. Dimoldenberg was right about one thing. You don’t have to have range. You just have to know which way the mob is moving."

Lee Kuan Yimby on X - "I looked deep into Yemen’s Khat addiction, and the scale of devastation is insane.   Data shows Yemeni citizens spend HALF of their total income on Khat.    Khat also uses 40% of their total water supply for no nutritional value while lack of water and starvation is extremely prevalent in Yemen.   Starvation in Yemen is beyond alarming. Over 18 million people, just over half of the country's population face acute hunger.   There is an estimated 50,000+ child deaths annually in Yemen from extreme hunger and secondary infections.   About 130-144 children die per day of starvation in Yemen.   The estimate for adults is 20-50 per day, so for some reason they allow children to bare the brunt of death by starvation while tending to Khat crop production and chewing addiction.  Why would there be no humanitarian aid to stop that? Because of The Jihadist militants that also own The Khat business in Yemen.   International aid funding to Yemen dropped due to The Houthis complete operational theft. They also launched a massive crackdown on humanitarian workers, carrying out abductions and detaining United Nations and NGO employees for ransom.  The Houthis essentially have a monopoly on the Khat business in Yemen.   Because they control the vast majority of Yemen's mountain ranges, where the country's khat is cultivated, the crop falls directly under Houthi territorial administration, the militant group has successfully monopolized the trade. They profit heavily from the national addiction of Khat by enforcing fees at militia checkpoint fees and taxation.   Cultivating khat requires an immense amount of water and the Houthis have seized all key water tables across western and northern Yemen, the Houthis effectively function as landlords to the farming networks. Farmers are dependent on the group for access to the fuel required to run irrigation pumps, allowing Houthi leadership to control the entire industry.   Yemen used to be the number one exporter of Coffee in the world and they ripped out almost every single Coffee farm for to produce Khat. Estimates indicate that up to 80% of Yemen's arable land was systematically converted to cultivate Khat. Khat uses four times the amounts of water that coffee does. Yemen is in severe drought conditions and the country is locked in a catastrophic environmental crisis driven by lack of rivers, rainfall and their addiction to Khat.   Khat is now so deeply embedded in Yemeni culture, so much so that it transcends the frontlines of the ongoing conflict. The trade is so vital that opposing military forces in Yemen often observe an unwritten daily ceasefire between noon to 4:00 PM allowing both sides to break combat, safely distribute the shipments, and gather to chew the leaf.   So to wrap this up, Jihadist Terrorists, that Hasan Piker says are awesome (The Houthis) were stealing all the international aid and holding it hostage to finance terror operations while continuing to be the main drivers behind Yemens Khat industry and addiction. All while hundreds of thousands of Yemenis continue to die of starvation.   I would like to say there is a change coming, but almost the entire population seem too focused on chewing Khat to do anything about it."
Damn Israel and British colonialism!

The cult of Palestinianism is fundamentally anti-British - "  If the scenes of a Battle of Britain memorial scaled and poppy wreaths trampled by pro-Palestinian activists shock you, you haven’t been paying attention.  In the monomaniacal cult that is Palestinianism, there is nothing else that exists. What is sacred or venerable or meaningful to you is, for them, just another place to attach that damned flag. That flag that is now as associated with London, Liverpool, and Birmingham as it is with Ramallah, Rafah, and Nablus. That flag which you can attach to as many lamp posts as you like in England without being accused of divisiveness.  Why has Britain been such a focal point for anti-Israel activism since October 7, 2023? Yes, our open-borders immigration policy has played its part. As too has our insistent, suicidal tolerance of people and cultures inimical to our own.  But there is something else at work. Palestinianism is outwardly anti-Zionist, but inwardly it grows from a shallow and ill-read sense of grievance against the British, their empire, and London’s historical sympathy for a Jewish state. They hate Israel, but they blame Britain. To the Palestinianists, Britain means Balfour, the original sin which enabled the entire Zionism project. Wave your own Palestinian flag all you want, assure them of your shared loathing for Israel if you wish, but it will make no difference.  This is a movement that draws on deep reserves of anti-British prejudice, and it is no more going to change the fact that it is going to recognise Israeli sovereignty over Jerusalem.  Britain would rather not face up to the enmity felt for it by the Palestinianists. We have more than enough mobs who hate our guts, thank you very much. Our fatal mistake is listening to them in good faith and striving to strike a reasonable balance between their campaign and that of their Israeli enemies. In doing so, we insist upon a false equivalence that treats these two causes as morally equal. This approach cannot survive honest scrutiny.  The cause of Zionism, the establishment and maintenance of a Jewish state in the ancient Land of Israel, has produced an advanced democracy, with a highly educated citizenry and burgeoning markets in technology, medical science, and military materiel.  By whichever metric you choose, the existence of the State of Israel is an objective good and has brought many benefits to Western civilisation, whether in computing, pharmaceuticals, or intelligence. In contrast stands the cause of Palestinianism. Not the cause of Palestine or the Palestinian people, among whose number there is a not insignificant segment which would rather live in peace with Israel than maintain this self-defeating jihad against Zionism.  No, it’s the Palestinian radicals and especially their self-appointed allies here in Britain, many of whom have been indoctrinated in national self-hatred by those madrasas of masochism, the universities. These people are Britons ashamed of their Britishness, or so detached from their national identity that they feel no shame at all.  They disregard the monuments to our dead because they do not regard them as their dead. They traipse over poppies because the poppy is a powerful symbol in this country, not in the one to which their emotions and their philosophy are ordered. Britain is just where Palestinianists live; Palestine is their country."
Left wingers and Muslims hate the West after all - it's their common enemy explaining the red-green alliance

Anti-Semitism in Ireland is ‘disaster waiting to happen’ - "An ADL report found that Ireland’s Jewish community, estimated to number about 2,200 people, reported 143 anti-Semitic incidents over a six-month period in 2025."

Meme - Brianna Wu @BriannaWu: "Kind of love Demi Lovato's response to people trying to drag her into free Palestine. "I'm a singer. I don't have an opinion on Middle East conflicts.""
ddlovato: Okay but do y'all realize, I don't have an opinion on middle eastern conflicts nor is it my place to have one being an American singer and you're asking me to choose a side?
that's literally asking me to choose a side. I will not choose a side. I went to a place, for religious purposes, THAT'S IT. well clearly I can't win with you unless I do what YOU want me to, so idk what to tell you "
Claiming that "If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor" is just "if you're not with us, you're against us". But that's only bad if you're a right winger. It's all very well to pretend that if an elephant has its foot on the tail of a mouse, the elephant must be in the wrong, but the mouse could be trying to kill the elephant. Using left wing logic, humans were evil for effectively eradicating the smallpox virus

Why a spate of gun-for-hire shootings in Toronto were likely paid for by Iran - "In recent years, the Iranian government and its intelligence service have been linked to plots and attacks in Germany, the Netherlands, the U.K., Australia and the United States.  Last May, the FBI arrested Mohammad Baqer al-Saadi, whom they claim is a senior member of Harakat Ashab al-Yamin al-Islamiya (HAYI), a militia group controlled by Iran's Revolutionary Guard. He now faces six terrorism related charges.  The indictment filed in New York State, alleges he helped plan and co-ordinate at least 18 attacks in Europe, as well as two more in Canada — the March 2026 shooting at the U.S. Consulate in Toronto and an assault on an unnamed synagogue. In June, Canada issued a joint statement with 20 other nations, condemning Iran's "lethal plotting and other malign actions" in Europe, North America and Australia.  "The relationship between Iranian security services and international and local criminal groups is long standing," the statement read. "Their use of these groups is deplorable."  Still, allegations of Iranian subterfuge continue, most recently in the U.K., following a foiled plot to attack a Royal Air Force base in England."
Damn Mossad!

Visegrád 24 on X - "Hamas is demanding approximately 10,000 Israeli shekels ($3,220) from private merchants for every truck carrying commercial goods into Gaza.  Hamas also requires merchants to conduct approximately 30% of their sales in cash to gain greater control over commercial revenues.  Israeli authorities also revealed that Hamas security personnel arrested and imprisoned a merchant's son after his father refused to pay the demanded fees."
Israel is so heartless!

Crazy Dating Profile / The Reality of Trans "Care" for FTMs

It seems anything trans related has a higher chance of being blocked on iFunny:


"Cami 24
Personal Trainer
NASM - CPT
96 miles away

I'm HIGH energy and looking for the same. No dad bods and no BMI over 22. I'm a single mom of one son, he is my everything. I'm looking for a partner and daddy for us both. If you are not a Democratic Socialist then we won't get along. No bigots and no closed minded people. Must vote Blue no matter Who! BLM, ACAB, LGBTQ+ Ally.

I am a trans woman, just giving you full disclosure. I am Pre-Op but next year I will be my new and complete self"

Pretty sure this would be blocked, so I'm not even trying:


Greg Karnes @realGregKarnes: "This is your friendly reminder that taking skin from a woman’s thigh to create a non-functional tube of skin that is supposed to resemble male genitalia is not healthcare."

Links - 18th November 2026 (1 - Get Woke, Go Broke: Bioware)

Commander Cody on X - "Andrew Wilson is the CEO and Chairman of EA, the man directly responsible for the axing of Mass Effect Studio BioWare and firing of 400 people across EA, 50 of those positions being at BioWare. You want a villain, it's this man."
Trutown on X - "Reminder that Andrew Wilson gave BioWare a year long extension to Dragon Age Inquisition, gave them the idea for flight in Anthem, and stoped them from going into a one game per year business model. Wilson supported BioWare every step of the way and it was BioWare who killed themselves because he was too lenient on them."
Grummz on X - "I don't know of many execs that would have given Bioware so many chances. It's just popular to blame capitalism and greed when the blame is just that the games didn't work...and the devs had control over that."

Meme - "BioWare: KOTOR *7 guys*
BioWare: DragonAge Veilguard *15 people, with 1-2 men*"

Meme - Pirat_Nation @Pirat_Nation: "I hope that adding that shit and owning the chuds was worth it, BioWare.  One of the best studios with a legendary franchise ruined for adding that non-binary shit and options for the modern audience, leaving out a trash game that no one liked, not even journalists.  Hope the franchise is given to a more competent studio."
"TATTOOS, SCARS, AND PAINT... Top Surgery Scars"

Dragon Age veteran shuts down The Veilguard haters: "The majority of people on a team the size of Veilguard’s had little or no say in the things you disliked about it"
Endymion on X - "Then that just proves BioWare was ideologically held hostage against their will by a small cabal of higher ups at the studio who drove that ship into an iceberg on purpose. Like I keep saying, the more you allow activists to have power the more this mass extinction event will continue.   FIRE ALL ACTIVISTS"

Why BioWare Was Always Doomed To Fail, The Moment EA Bought Them - "In 2005, private equity firm, Elevation Partners bought BioWare and another studio, Pandemic, under a holding company called VG Holding Corp."
Given that Mass Effect came out a month after EA bought Bioware, Mass Effect 2 which was an even bigger commercial and critical hit came even later, and Dragon Age came out after EA bought it, framing it as EA buying the Mass Effect and Dragon Age studio is rich, but this is the usual cope. Of course, private equity/EA are always evil and decisions made 20 years ago doomed BioWare, not the lousy games they put in the last decade because they wanted to pwn the chuds

God Promises To Spare BioWare If He Can Find Ten Developers Who Are Heterosexual White Men | Babylon Bee

Endymion on X - "This is exactly why BioWare went under. You have “games journalists” like Fran here who will cry when a studio goes under but then publicly admits he doesn’t even support the studios or play the games they make.   Why do you care then? You could’ve saved modern BioWare by opening your wallet, but you didn’t. You’re proving exactly why they went under because they catered to people like YOU & what did you do in return? Nothing. You let them rot.   So I ask why should any company make games for people like you Fran? You guys don’t buy games, you guys don’t connect with players so who exactly do you speak for?   Ironically he says “I have no skin in the game” take yeah we can tell & that’s the problem. You don’t care about the games industry anymore & it shows.   No wonder legacy media is getting annihilated by independent voices when this is the caliber of journalist they got defending their practices.   Buy some fucking video games you larper  & maybe people will care what journalists have to say again. But we both know you’ll beg for free codes cause that’s what you feel legitimizes you.   No wonder even games media is having layoffs man. Who the fuck do these people represent but being corporate boot lickers?"

BioWare's Future Was In Jeopardy Well Before EA's $55 Billion Acquisition, Analysts Say - "Games industry analysts told IGN that BioWare was likely doomed well before EA’s $55 billion acquisition... Harding-Rolls added that the commercial failure of BioWare's last game, Dragon Age: The Veilguard, played a part in BioWare's demise. And let's remember that 2017's Mass Effect: Andromeda and 2019's Anthem also failed to meet EA's expectations.  “Unfortunately, the studio’s recent big-budget releases have not performed well enough commercially," he said. "Ampere data shows that Bioware’s latest release at the end of 2024 — Dragon Age: The Veilguard — has sold an estimated 1.9 million units globally across PlayStation, Xbox, and Steam up to the end of September, way below internal targets. The changing nature of high-end gaming and the need to cut costs means that it is likely that Bioware’s future was under discussion before EA was acquired by the PIF and its partners.”"
Of course, left wingers think that EA should've improved conditions for staff instead of being "greedy" and shutting a loss-making studio down

Earl of Olay on X - "You didn't figure it out.  How much money did Anthem lose you?  $200 million in losses.  Veilguard lost you another $300 million.    That's about what Gears of War is on track to lose Microsoft.  $400+ million development and only 230,000 copies sold in the first month.  They need 11 million copies sold to break even and 14-15 million to hit that magic 30% profit that sets a studio up to make another game.  If you don't make games we like, we don't buy the games.  It's really simple.  You aren't entitled to sell trash just because you think you worked hard on it.  This isn't like modern art in a NY gallery.  We require substance, quality, and we don't want your 2016 politics rammed down our throats."

Florian Schrie on X - "I mean, a developer actually did make an even-better-sequel to the best game of all time, it's called Baldur's Gate 3 and sold twice as many copies as Bioware's best selling game. It just happened to be from a different studio completely free from publisher constraints. (But yes, EA managing to sink both the Mass Effect and the Dragon Age franchises is beyond depressing)"

JSONmaxxing on X - "the best Bioware games (up to Mass Effect 3 in 2012) were made by three high-IQ Canadian doctors, who got bored with making games, and changed careers to medicine, poker, and craft beer.      they left the company in the hands of a bunch of young programmers and creative writing majors who didn't know what they were doing. I don't even blame them for failing to meet expectations. The cultural wars stuff didn't help, but fundamentally Inquisition/Andromeda/Veilguard flopped because they were just bad games made by people with no vision."

Arthur Kimes on X - "Put out crap the work warriors praise* (but don't buy) and that insults and turns off the actual players/buyers... and this is what happens. And some other companies don't seem to learn from this! *veilguard"

Hoyvin on X - "If only they made games for their actual audience."
FF7 Tifa Fan on X - "Maybe the so-called "games industry" can cease with the incessant desire of game developers who seem to fundamentally hate their target audience of straight men and does everything in their power to subvert this while being cheered on by hack game journos?"
GrumpyAndCynical on X - "If only 'gamers' hadn't been written off as hateful misogynists, trolls, and right-wingers, people to be re-educated rather than entertained."

Kyler on X - "They hired a bunch of gluestick eating retards with no idea what's cool or compelling and watered down their games for console audiences. They haven't made a great game in TWO DECADES. Who gives a fuck! Larian had to step in and make BG3 because bioware hasn't been an rpg developer since Jade Empire."

panthuraaxx on X - "We told you so.  You spent a decade turning the last great fantasy RPG series into a sanitized, lecture-heavy, character-customization-first experience that prioritized modern checklists over the writing, reactivity, and edge that actually built the brand, and then acted shocked when the core audience that made Baldur’s Gate, KOTOR, Origins, and the Mass Effect trilogy profitable didn’t show up in the numbers you needed.  Now the studio that once defined the genre is writing its own obituary and ending the next Mass Effect before it even really started.   Congratulations on the “shared adventure.”  And thank god you are out of a job, no one deserves it more.   Welcome home!"

Dantics on X - "I can finally talk about Mass Effect Universe. Since Bioware closed I can now reveal that I was part of the Mass Effect Council, saw what BioWare was building, and provided feedback during development.
• Set 600+ years after the Reaper War
• You play as a customizable N7 agent
• Instead of being a walking gun rack, you're a cross between John Wick and James Bond
• Shepard's legacy preserved, regardless of your ending
• A galaxy divided into three major factions
• Humanity, Krogan, Batarians, and more allied together
• Council races forming their own alliance
• The Geth emerging as a third superpower
• A galactic Cold War instead of another Reaper style invasion with a shadowy adversary
• Geth-built megastructures
• Connections between the Milky Way and Andromeda
• Experimental technology implanted in you as a unique point of difference
• Hacking and manipulating the environment
• See through walls, identify systems, remotely trigger hazards and more
• Handcrafted missions like ME1-3
• But with Hitman-style freedom in how you complete them
• Brutal close-range executions
• Squadmates who can clash with each other
• Romance wasn't being sanitised
• Liara returns - now an incredibly powerful Asari Matriarch
From what I saw, BioWare was making Mass Effect for us, the fans, not for people who don't exist.  It looked incredible. And now we may never get to play it. Find out more here: https://youtu.be/ZOWrTNazZxM #SaveMassEffect"

WelovegiantessAI on X - "I don’t buy it. How can you claim this game was made for the fans, when you said the exact same thing about *Dragon Age™: The Veilguard*—that it was made for the fans? Why should we believe that? For the past 10 years, you’ve done nothing but make games that *aren’t*for the fans"

Class on X - "If we can remove the grifter bullshit and put aside whatever opinion you have of their last 2 games for 2 seconds, this is objectively a fucking awful thing that just keeps happening again and again. 400 people out of a job because the industry continues to cannibalize itself"
Kyle Castorena on X - "It's not a terrible thing because those 400 people were terrible at their job. Nobody twisted their arm to force a "coming out" scene in Dragon Age Veilguard. They told us "If you don't like my game, don't buy my game," and we didn't, and they were proud of it."

Nick Calandra on X - "Weird, I guess the people actually sad about BioWare closing aren’t their fans, only you are. Interesting."
SirD on X - "Yes Nick, that is exactly the point.  You guys aren't sad BioWare closed "because you're a fan." You're sad that we have yet another point in the long pattern which proves "nobody likes your shit woke games."  BioWare's fans ARE happy it closed. Want to know why? It's because the company we loved was taken over by weird, self-absorbed left-wing activists wearing game developer skin-suits.   They proceeded to take a franchise consisting of politically incorrect, male power-fantasy games... games that overwhelmingly appealed to and were made for straight men... and twist/contort said franchise into a weird, insufferable gender non-conformist trauma fantasy layered with not so thinly veiled propaganda.  Hence why nobody bought it. Hope this helps."
Weird. We're told that having high standards and being critical shows that you love something

Edge Field on X - "BioWare n'est pas mort à cause du wokisme, mais grâce à nos boycotte.  Et BioWare a été boycotté parce qu'il était devenu merdique.  Et il était devenu merdique à CAUSE du wokisme...  Donc ouai. Go woke, go broke. Un studio fait de la merde, internet le puni. Et c'est normal."

saira on X - "all the chuds coming out of the woodworks acting like they know what happens behind the scenes in big companies, acting like being gay in a game is the reason a studio falls apart when baldurs gate 3 is evidence of the contrary"
Mostly Peaceful Michael on X - "You are confusing "a quality game that includes some gay stuff (even some possible bestiality)" with "a garbage game whose main purpose is to promote woke nonsense." If you look back at the "chud" YouTube reviews, you'll see that Baldur's Gate 3 was almost universally praised while Dragon's Age Veilgard was a dumpster fire.  If you want to say it wasn't just the woke nonsense in Veilgard that killed Bioware, you're right. What killed Bioware was the DEI hiring practices that led them to replace qualified male developers who built Bioware with retarded women sporting neon hair and rainbow flags. DEI kills the studios because they no longer have the talent to succeed. The massive flop last game is a consequence of the DEI incompetence, not the cause."
In other words, DEI destroys companies not just by being imposed on their products but also their staff

Correactor on X - "Baldur's Gate 3 has: A trans character, voiced by a trans person, who snaps at someone for deadnaming them and has a diary about their transition. Body types with mix-and-match genitalia. A bear you can fuck. So why didn't it fail? It's almost like quality is what matters."
Noir 浮世 on X - "You guys should stop using Baldur's Gate 3 to cope with your delusions. It is true that it has gays and diversity. But it also has homophobia, racism, and even Christian references, depending on your playthrough
- You can kill Astarion almost immediately
- You can kill a whole village to pound Minthara
- You can conquer the land
- You can bang the hot demon chick and piss off Wyll
BG3 is not a woke nor chud game....it's a complete game famous for having a TON of routes and ways to play"

Leonor on X - "In Baldur's Gate 3 you can be trans and queer and that game sold over 20 mil copies. The chuds saying the reason Bioware didn't sell well with their recent games was because of "activism" are absolutele delusional troglodytes the need to go outside."
The Questbroski on X - "Baldur's Gate 3 lets you make any decision about any thing that happens in the game, it never chastises you, it never preaches at you, it simply lets you make choices and live with the consequences of those choices.  You can kill every trans, homosexual, demi gender weirdo in the game and life goes on as normal.  It never once lectures you about how it's bad to kill specifically LGBT characters. It just lets you do it.  You can do whatever you want in the game.  Dragqueen Gays: The Failguard offered you no such freedom. It was a top to bottom lecture.  Drag Queen Story DAYS. Not hour."
Left Wingers need to find a cope to explain why even though BG3 was "woke" it still did so well. Of course there are some. But most of the time as usual they just make up elaborate strawmen in their head and then call others hypocrites for not adhering to those strawmen

Bruwulf on X - "Baldur's Gate 3 was always going to sell well. It was the sequel to one of the most famous CRPGs of all time, from the developers behind the best CRPG games currently made, set in the most popular TTRPG setting for the most popular TTRPG in the entire world for the last fifty years, during a period where a combination of pop culture (e.g. Stranger Things, a recent theatrical movie release), pandemic social shifts, and gaming live streams like Critical Roll had boosted D&D into an absolutely unprecedented and unforseen height of popularity among both geeks and normies alike.  It basically could not fail. It could have been the most warmed over turd in gaming history and it still would have done well. Trying to use BG3 specifically to prove any point is useless as a result, because the massive conflux of pre-existing market and automatic marketing boost is not replicable with any random game.  The only takeaway you can actually make is that it's possible to still succeed despite the inclusion of "woke" elements, not that those things do not, in isolation, hurt a product."
The cope is amusing. But left wingers really do think this way, which is why they think if they wreck beloved franchises it's not their fault

Endymion on X - "Meanwhile the most common Baldur’s Gate 3 character was a white straight male human paladin for a reason. That’s why the game sold, they also kept the other stuff behind player choice. So if you didn’t want to see that stuff you didn’t have to. Of course the games journalist  called it “generic” cause they wanted to change behaviors but it didn’t work.   Straight male Paladin ftw as god intended"
Ermin Hamidovic on X - "Paladin is the important part, because the intent is to smite the degeneracy. They didn't just avoid the subversive BS, they actively wanted to fight it."

𝔗𝔢𝔫𝔢𝔟𝔯𝔞𝔢 on X - "I wish that I could say that takes like this were out of genuine ignorance, but they're not...it's just grasping at straws to maintain the illusion that they're right.  No.  The success of Baldur's Gate 3 doesn't prove activism isn't to blame for the collapse of these studios and their progressive pet-projects...or their co-opting of previously beloved IPs.  It proves that the slander and libel that activists, both in and out of the media/industry, directed towards the majority has always been exactly that: buzzwords used to smear criticism and snuff out dissent by an ideological demographic that's the Left's equivalent to Westboro Baptist Church.  Even from the early days of GamerGate, you were all told this...and continued to sling the buzzwords regardless, aided by a games media as infested by this cancerous ideology as the industry itself.  The gaming community has always been egalitarian, but never politically correct...nor accepting of extremist ideologies trying to preach down to us and take over the industry.  I'm hard pressed to believe anyone is iodic enough to actually, genuinely, not understand the difference.  So, I can only conclude that its intellectual dishonesty born out of fear towards losing the power that these ideologues have gotten themselves throughout the industry.  No amount of mental gymnastics is going to fix that...because it will continue to financially fail and, eventually, no amount of explanation you can give will enshroud the reason.  Type until your fingers go numb, it won't matter."

God Empress of Mankind on X - "Pretending that letting modern-day politics bleed into their work didn't burn through what little goodwill they had left is delusional at best and disingenuous at worst.  David Gaider, the creator of Dragon Age, is gay. He wrote bisexual characters without making their sexuality their entire personality or sacrificing the worldbuilding in the process.  Leliana and Zevran were bisexual, and their backgrounds reflected the cultures they came from. Alistair and Morrigan were straight and had their own preferences. Wynne, Sten, and Oghren weren't interested in the player romantically. They were written like REAL PEOPLE, with their sexualities woven naturally into the narrative.  You wouldn't necessarily know a character's sexuality unless you took the time to get to know them, exhaust their dialogue, and try flirting with them. Their identities were part of who they were, not the entirety of who they were. They didn't blurt it out over tea.  And the worst part is that Baldur's Gate 3 proved you could still do this. It integrated sexuality and identity into the world and its characters without constantly shining a spotlight on them. It let the writing speak for itself, and people accepted it and moved on.  Meanwhile, the writing in Veilguard was lazy as all hell.  When you treat your audience like they're fucking three years old, assume they're too stupid to understand anything without having it spelled out for them, and gut a beloved IP in the process of trying to prove a point, don't be surprised when you alienate the very community you're supposedly trying to uplift.  Queer people are people. They're not special, they're not props, and they're not fucking mouthpieces. Write them like people."
So much for the cope that BioWare was always woke. Another cope I saw was that people didn't realize that the old games were woke because the chuds are too stupid, and that if you reevaluate the old games today they would be denounced as woke too but the chuds are too stupid to realize that

red on X - "“I don’t want politics in video games” Fallout. Dying Light. Bioshock. Metal Gear Solid. Assassins Creed All of these games are highly political, it isn’t that you don’t want politics in video games, it’s that you want the politics to suit you and only you."
Blu on X - "None of those games have Real World, Immersion Disrupting, 4th Wall Breaking, Message Preaching Politics. A game can be political, if you invent the politics that exists within the game, not import Real World Politics to be represented within the game. That's called AgitProp."
Alex on X - "Political themes in video games are not the same as forcing identity politics onto the player People who make these statements are simply trying to sweep their own political views into games because it’s what they want to see and are literally lying to you"

Daniel Friedman on X - "It’s not that I don’t want “politics” in video games. I don’t want a multi-hour HR training video about how to navigate nonbinary and trans pronouns and identities in video games. Or really, it’s fine for that to be in video games. Do what you want. I just won’t buy it."
Obskura on X - "It's so funny how we clarified this almost a decade ago but they have no other argument left so they hold on to it and keep pretending."
Adam Wasem on X - "They can't help themselves, their delusions control them. They truly believed that making the woke stuff, formerly occasional and optional, instead mandatory and ubiquitous, was some kind of righteous mission to rebuke the evil chuds. If they even contemplated negative consequences, they convinced themselves they were a small price to pay."
Michael Choi, MD on X - "What even is the rationale here? Like, “Hey before you do this fun thing you’re paying us for, we’re going to make you jump through the most irritating, lame hoop possible and expect it won’t dissuade you at all.”"
Left wing logic: JRR Tolkien was a hypocrite for criticising CS Lewis for being too heavy-handed in jamming Christian allegory into Narnia, because you can find Christian themes in Tolkien's work too.

Salzige Cayde-Herringe on X - "Ok, so don't buy it. But that means you can't run your dumbass mouth about it either"
Daniel Friedman on X - "I didn’t buy it. And millions of gamers who had previously bought BioWare games also didn’t buy it. Almost nobody bought it. And that is why it lost $200 million, and that is why EA closed the studio."

Blast Professing on X - "heaven forbid you expand beyond horizons artificially capped for you by bigots + fashies, the future, by your standard, looks remarkably similar to the present + past, never reaching beyond them, never desiring anything beyond your own cage of privilege. that's fine, stay bland."
Daniel Friedman on X - "I am “bland” because I don’t want to play a game where there are multiple hours of discussion about what pronouns a butch dragon woman should use?"
Forksmith on X - "Keep not being able to sell stuff, I guess"
James Rowland on X - "You know what you get with that, is cardboard paper thin reductionist checkboxes. Not expanding horizons."

Daniel Friedman on X - "Yes, BioWare went broke because it went woke...
Left leaning commentators and analysts attribute the closure to numerous causes: Polygon points out that EA was recently taken private by an investor group backed by the Saudi sovereign wealth fund and Jared Kushner's investment firm, they attribute the closure to the new ownership and the cost-cutting necessitated by the debt placed on EA as a result of the acquisition's financing. IGN and Bloomberg report that BioWare and its new "Mass Effect" game came up on the chopping block because EA's new owners decided the publisher didn't need two large sci-fi themed games, and cancelled this one in favor of a new "Star Wars: Battlefront" game. Kotaku echoes a common argument that BioWare's failure played out over more than a decade, due to management pushing a studio famed for intricate, story-driven role-playing games to make a cash-cow live-service title, culminating in the disastrous "Anthem" in 2019, a gargantuan "Destiny"-style looter-shooter that failed to gain an audience. All of this is nominally true, and yet this complexity is being invoked to obscure a truth that is much simpler and more straightforward: BioWare was shut down as a result of the failure of its previous game, "Dragon Age: The Veilguard," a massive single-player RPG title that lost an estimated $200 million after a decade-long development cycle. And the reason "Dragon Age: The Veilguard" failed so spectacularly -- the reason this game reached an audience of only about 1.5 million players after the previous game in the series sold over 12 million copies -- is because its content alienated the audience. The lead creatives on "Dragon Age: The Veilguard" were designer Corinne Busche who is an outspoken trans activist and writer Patrick "Trick" Weekes, who self-describes as pansexual and nonbinary. The game focuses substantially on LGBT subject matter, including a major questline about helping a hulking female dragon-slayer discover her nonbinary identity. It is probably the most LGBT-focused mainstream entertainment product ever made at this scale. The gaming press clearly understood that this was an LGBT game during its launch window, and the coverage of it substantially focused on that aspect of the game. IGN assigned the game to a reviewer who identifies as nonbinary and praised the game's focus on "gender stuff." This reviewer gave the game a 9/10 which ended up being substantially higher than the review consensus around the game. Polygon published an extensive feature about trans and nonbinary content in the game, and PC Gamer published its own extensive story about the LGBT content, calling the game a "leap forward in trans inclusion." Outside of "professional" games media, however, YouTubers and Streamers were having a very different discussion of the game. Of the 10 most-viewed YouTube videos discussing the game, three are from the right-wing streamer Asmongold who focused heavily on criticizing the game's LGBT content and storylines. Meanwhile, non-political gaming commentators didn't criticize the LGBT content directly, but didn't praise it either. An extremely viral and harshly negative review from Skill Up complained that the game had simplified its combat relative to previous "Dragon Age" titles, while videogamedunkey mocked the writing for its clumsy exposition and constant repetition. None of the most-viewed videos are from fans reacting positively to the game. None of the most-viewed videos are about how to do things in the game, like beating bosses, solving puzzles or finding secrets. There were not a lot of people watching videos of cool boss fights or exciting story events or discussions of the different choices players can make in the game and their outcomes, but clips of various scenes in the game dealing with nonbinary identity and discussing pronouns or modeling apologies for misgendering were widely shared. In short, the LGBT content dominated discourse surrounding the game in its critical launch period, and even core gamers who were okay with the LGBT content felt abandoned by the game's design direction, which everyone could see was aimed at a different audience than previous BioWare RPGs. That new audience did not emerge, and the established audience did not buy the game. Although BioWare was not finally, formally shuttered until October of 2026, the repercussions of the failure of "Dragon Age: The Veilguard" manifested much sooner. In January of 2025, EA reported on an earnings call that the game had sold only about half of what it had expected, and reduced the full-year earnings guidance for the entire EA portfolio as a result. Bioware was restructured and hit with layoffs in early February of 2025. When the new ownership group took over in August of 2026, Bioware had already been cut from a staff of over 200 people during Veilguard's development to a skeleton crew of about 50. Whatever role other factors played, BioWare was a full-force AAA gaming studio with the backing of a major publisher during the production and rollout of "Dragon Age: The Veilguard," and the studio was substantially dismantled after the catastrophic failure of that game. And a substantial reason "Dragon Age: The Veilguard" failed was that it alienated the traditional gamer audience that had previously supported the studio with extremely extensive content about transgender and nonbinary identity and issues. In short, this is the clearest and most unambiguous example of "go woke, go broke" ever."
Time to condemn idiot YouTubers for brainwashing the masses into not buying the game! This is why left wingers want to take over and censor every platform - so they can propagandise people to push the left wing agenda

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Truth About the Arab Refugees (The Truth About the "Nakba") (1/4)

"ONLY a George Orwell or a Franz Kafka could have done justice to the story of the Arab refugee problem. For twenty years the world has been indoctrinated with a vision of its origins, its scope, the responsibilities for its solution. The intent of this picture is, roughly, that in 1948 the Jewish people launched an attack on the Arab inhabitants of Palestine, drove them out, and thus established the State of Israel. The number of innocent peaceloving Arabs thus turned refugee was—here you may insert any figure that occurs to you, such as a million, one and a half million, two million. Justice demands that the refugees be restored to their homes, and until that day the world (everyone, that is, except the Arab people) must care for their upkeep.
The Arabs are the only declared refugees who became refugees not by the action of their enemies or because of well-grounded fear of their enemies, but by the initiative of their own leaders. For nearly a generation those leaders have willfully kept as many people as they possibly could in degenerating squalor, preventing their rehabilitation, and holding out to all of them the hope of return and of “vengeance” on the Jews of Israel, to whom they have transferred the blame for their plight.
The fabrication can probably most easily be seen in the simple circumstance that at the time the alleged cruel expulsion of Arabs by Zionists was in progress, it passed unnoticed. Foreign newspapermen who covered the war of 1948 on both sides did indeed write about the flight of the Arabs, but even those most hostile to the Jews saw nothing to suggest that it was not voluntary. In the three months during which the major part of the flight took place—April, May, and June, 1948—the London Times, at that time [openly] hostile to Zionism, published eleven leading articles on the situation in Palestine in addition to extensive news reports and articles. In none was there even a hint of the charge that the Zionists were driving the Arabs from their homes.
More interesting still, no Arab spokesman mentioned the subject. At the height of the flight, on April 27, Jamal Husseini, the Palestine Arabs’ chief representative at the United Nations, made a long political statement, which was not lacking in hostility toward the Zionists; he did not mention refugees. Three weeks later (while the flight was still in progress) the Secretary General of the Arab League, Azzam Pasha, made a fiercely worded political statement on Palestine; it contained not a word about refugees.
THE ARAB REFUGEES were not driven from Palestine by anyone. The vast majority left, whether of their own free will or at the orders or exhortations of their leaders, always with the same reassurance—that their departure would help in the war against Israel. Attacks by Palestinian Arabs on the Jews had begun two days after the United Nations adopted its decision of November 29, 1947, to divide Western Palestine into an Arab and a Jewish state. The seven neighboring Arab states—Syria, Lebanon, Transjordan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and Egypt—then prepared to invade the country as soon as the birth of the infant State of Israel was announced. Their victory was certain, they claimed, but it would be speeded and made easier if the local Arab population got out of the way. The refugees would come back in the wake of the victorious Arab armies and not only recover their own property but also inherit the houses and farms of the vanquished and annihilated Jews. Between December 1, 1947, and May 15, 1948, the clash was largely between bands of local Arabs, aided in diverse ways by the disintegrating British authority, and the Jewish fighting organizations.
The earliest voluntary refugees were understandably the wealthier Arabs of the towns, who made a comparatively leisurely departure in December 1947 and in early 1948. At that state, departure had not yet been proclaimed as a policy or recognized as a poten
tial propaganda weapon. The Jaffa newspaper Ash Sha’ab thus wrote on January 30, 1948:
The first group of our fifth column consists of those who abandon their houses and businesses and go to live elsewhere. . . . At the first sign of trouble they take to their heels to escape sharing the burden of struggle.
The weekly As Sarih of Jaffa used even more scathing terms on March 30, 1948, to accuse the inhabitants of Sheikh Munis and other villages in the neighborhood of Tel Aviv of “bringing down disgrace on us all” by “abandoning their villages.” On May 5 the Jerusalem correspondent of the London Times was reporting: “The Arab streets are curiously deserted and, evidently following the poor example of the more moneyed class there has been an exodus from Jerusalem too, though not to the same extent as in Jaffa and Haifa.”
As the local Arab offensive spread during the late winter and early spring of 1948, the Palestinian Arabs were urged to take to the hills, so as to leave the invading Arab armies unencumbered by a civilian population. Before the State of Israel had been formally declared—and while the British still ruled the country—over 200,000 Arabs left their homes in the coastal plain of Palestine.
These exhortations came primarily from their own local leaders. Monsignor George Hakim, then Greek Catholic Bishop of Galilee, the leading Christian personality in Palestine for many years, told a Bierut newspaper in the summer of 1948, before the flight of Arabs had ended:
The refugees were confident that their absence would not last long, and that they would return within a week or two. Their leaders had promised them that the Arab Armies would crush the “Zionist gangs” very quickly and that there was no need for panic or fear of a long exile. [Sada al Janub, August 16, 1969]

The exodus was indeed common knowledge. The London weekly Economist reported on October 2,1948:

Of the 62,000 Arabs who formerly lived in Haifa not more than 5,000 or 6,000 remained. Various factors influenced their decision to seek safety in flight. There is but little doubt that the most potent of the factors were the announcements made over the air by the Higher Arab Executive, urging the Arabs to quit. ... It was clearly intimated that those Arabs who remained in Haifa and accepted Jewish protection would be regarded as renegades.

And the Near East Arabic Broadcasting Station from Cyprus stated on April 3, 1949:

It must not be forgotten that the Arab Higher Committee encouraged the refugees' flight from their
homes in Jaffa, Haifa, and Jerusalem.

Even in retrospect, in an effort to describe the deliberateness of the flight, the leading Arab propagandist of the day, Edward Atiyah (then Secretary of the Arab League Office in London) reaffirmed the facts:

This wholesale exodus was due partly to the belief of the Arabs, encouraged by the boasting of an unrealistic Arab press and the irresponsible utterances of some of the Arab leaders that it could be only a matter of some weeks before the Jews were defeated by the armies of the Arab States and the Palestinian Arabs enabled to re-enter and retake possession of their country. [The Arabs, London, p. 183] 

Kenneth Bilby, one of the American correspondents who covered Palestine for several years before
and during the war of 1948, soon afterward wrote a book on his experience and observations. In it he reported: 

The Arab exodus, initially at least, was encouraged by many Arab leaders, such as Haj Amin el Husseini, the exiled pro-Nazi Mufti of Jerusalem, and by the Arab Higher Committee for Palestine. They viewed the first wave of Arab setbacks as merely transitory. Let the Palestine Arabs flee into neighboring countries. It would serve to arouse the other Arab peoples to greater effort, and when the Arab invasion struck, the Palestinians could return to their homes and be compensated with the property of Jews driven into the sea. [New Star in the Near East, New York, 1950, pp. 30-31]
After the war the Palestine Arab leaders did try to help people-including their own-to forget that it was they who had called for the exodus in the early spring of 1948. They now blamed the leaders of the invading Arab states themselves. These had added their voices to the exodus call, though not until some weeks after the Palestine Arab Higher Committee had taken a stand.

The war was not yet over when Emil Ghoury, Secretary of the Arab High Committee, the official
leadership of the Palestinian Arabs, stated in an interview with a Beirut newspaper:

I do not want to impugn anybody but only to help the refugees. The fact that there are these refugees is the direct consequence of the action of the Arab States in opposing partition and the Jewish State. The Arab States agreed upon this policy unanimously and they must share in the solution of the problem. [Daily Telegraph, September 6, 1948]
In retrospect, the Jordanian newspaper Falastin wrote on February 19, 1949:
The Arab States encouraged the Palestine Arabs to leave their homes temporarily in order to be out of the way of the Arab invasion armies.

 Nimr el Hawari, the Commander of the Palestine Arab Youth Organization, in his book Sir Am Nakbah ("The Secret Behind the Disaster", published in Nazareth in 1952), more specially quoted the Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri Said. Nuri, he wrote, had thun- dered: "We will smash the country with our guns and obliterate every place the Jews seek shelter in. The Arabs should conduct their wives and children to safe areas until the fighting has died down."

Equally specifically brought to public notice was the part played by the chief spokesman for the combined Arab states, the Secretary General of the Arab League himself. Habib Issa, in the New York Lebanese daily newspaper Al Hoda wrote on June 8, 1951:

The Secretary General of the Arab League, Azzam Pasha, assured the Arab peoples that the occupation of Palestine and of Tel Aviv would be as simple as a military promenade. ... He pointed out that they were already on the frontiers and that all the millions the Jews had spent on land and economic development would be easy booty, for it would be a simple matter to throw Jews into the Mediterranean. ... Brotherly advice was given to the Arabs of Palestine to leave their land, homes, and property and to stay temporarily in neighboring fraternal states, lest the guns of the invading Arab armies mow them down.
As late as 1952 the charge had the official stamp of the Arab Higher Committee. In a memorandum to
the Arab League states, the Committee wrote: 

Some of the Arab leaders and their ministers in Arab capitals ... declared that they welcomed the immigration of Palestinian Arabs into the Arab countries until they saved Palestine. Many of the Palestinian Arabs were misled by their declarations. ... It was natural for those Palestinian Arabs who felt impelled to leave their country to take refuge in Arab lands ... and to stay in such adjacent places in order to maintain contact with their country so that to return to it would be easy when, according to the promises of many of those responsible in the Arab countries (promises which were given wastefully), the time was ripe. Many were of the opinion that such an opportunity would come in the hours between sunset and sunrise.

Most pointed of all was the comment of one of the refugees themselves, "The Arab governments told us:
Get out so that we can get in. So we got out, but they did not get in."

When the onslaught of the local Arabs had been in progress for over four months, and a month before the planned invasion by the seven Arab states, about half the population still remained in the area mapped out by the United Nations as the Jewish state. Now began the fantastic phase of the exodus. A large part of the population panicked. Suddenly the countryside was filled with rumors and alleged reports of Jewish "atrocities." A highly colored report of a battle near Jerusalem became the driving theme. At the village of Dir Yassin, one of the bases of the Arab forces maintaining pressure on the Jerusalem-Tel Aviv road, an assault by the "dissident" Irgun Zvai Leumi and the FFI (Stern Group) had continued for eight hours before the village was finally captured, and then only with the help of a Palmach armored car which arrived on the scene unexpectedly. The element of surprise having been lost, the Arab soldiers could turn every house in the village into a fortress. Jewish casualties amounted to one-third of the attacking force (40 out of 120). The Arabs, barricading themselves in the houses, had omitted to evacuate women and children, many of whom were thus killed during the attack. 

The Arab leaders seized on the opportunity to tell an utterly fantastic story of a "massacre," which was disseminated throughout the world by all the arms of British propaganda. The accepted "orthodox" version to this day, it has served enemies of Israel and anti- Semites faithfully.   

The effect of the story was immediate and electric. The British officer who had done most in the years before 1948 to build up the Transjordanian Army, General Glubb Pasha, wrote in the London Daily Mail on August 12, 1948: "The Arab civilians panicked and fled ignominiously. Villages were frequently abandoned before they were threatened by the progress of war." And the refugee from Dir Yassin, Yunes Ahmed Assad, has soberly recorded that "The Arab exodus from other villages was not caused by the actual battle, but by the exaggerated description spread by Arab leaders to incite them to fight the Jews" (Al Urdun, April 9, 1953).

Another quarter of a million Arabs thus left the area of the State of Israel in the late spring and early
summer of 1948."

--- The Truth About the Arab Refugees in The American Zionist (1974) / Samuel Katz (originally in Battleground: Fact and Fantasy in Palestine) 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Latest posts (which you might not see on this page)

powered by Blogger | WordPress by Newwpthemes